Carlos Accioly
1y ago
Business results by finding the actions that work
It was 56 years ago that men first walked on the moon. Or did they?
Neil deGrasse Tyson tells the story of an acquaintance who doubts it. The story teaches a lesson about data and decision-making.
Tyson asked the man what evidence would convince him that men had been on the moon. The guy said that he'd be convinced by photos of the landing site. When Tyson showed him the photos, the man said he remained unconvinced because the pictures could have been faked.
That's when Tyson said "I'm done with you."
Why did Tyson do that? Why didn't he insist, produce more evidence?
Because the guy was not trying to decide whether to believe in the moon landing. He had already made up his mind.
What's the rational way to use data for decision-making?
1. Declare what you currently believe in.
2. Define what evidence would make you change your mind.
3. Look for that data.
4. If you can't find it, strengthen your belief. If you do find it, change your mind.
But here's how many people, including Tyson's skeptic, decide:
- If the available data agrees with what you believe in, exhibit it as proof. If it doesn't, reject the data.
Those people are immune to evidence that contradicts what they choose to believe.