User Avatar

Chirag Shah

Property Deep Dives

4y ago

Sharing learnings and epiphanies as a passive real estate investor (8 units) and real estate technology product manager (5 yrs).

How We Contested An Appraisal and Added $30K to A Property's Value
Chirag Shah

It was our second investment property, we were excited to be growing - that was until the numbers started coming in.

We purchased it for $65K, added $20K in value, and expected it to appraise at $120k. It came back at $73K, we were devastated. Not knowing what to do, we asked our lender what our options were. He suggested that we consider 'fighting' the appraisal. He added the chances of winning were slim but worth a shot.

If we were fighting, we were going to be prepared.

We conducted some basic research and went to work. Here are the steps we took.

Reviewed the appraisal and notate key deductions

We started by looking at which items the appraiser knocked us for. By going item by item, we highlighted items that we felt were poorly analyzed. In the process, we also paid close attention to the properties that the appraiser used to compare our property to.

This took us to our next step.

Got comparables for recently sold properties

Were these all the properties that were recently sold? No.

There were several properties that were sold more recently and had similar features but were not included as comparables. In fact, these were the ones that we used to estimate the value of our property.

With the key deductions in mind and more appropriate comparables to consider, we took the final step.

Wrote up a request for revision with rationale

Our detailed and concise report included the improvements we'd made and a recommendation to compare our property to different properties.

We even went as far as using the same appraisal framework and adding photos to the report.

Within 24 hrs we were informed our value was reassessed to $103K!

In the process not only did we learn to never give up but also how appraisers think.