It was 8:30 on a Tuesday evening, and I received this message from a lender of mine:
"I'm sad to hear that, but I'll be here with open arms."
The statement wasn't surprising based on what had transpired throughout the day. Because the market was expected to take a negative turn I had to be aggressive and quickly lock in rates. In the process, I chose to shop between three lenders (it's only prudent as an investor). I decided to move ahead with a lender I had just met, but unfortunately, I had to one let one of my favorite ones down.
These are the steps I took to negotiate the best rate I could find on a time crunch while also ensuring I kept my options for the future.
Get loan estimates
Lenders will give you two types of estimates - verbal and paper.
Verbal ones don't matter. They just get the conversation started. Make sure to get a loan estimate document as quickly as possible so you know what they can actually offer. The estimate will break down costs, rates, and everything you'll need to negotiate.
Share estimates with the competitors
When you have estimates on hand, share them amongst the competitors.
This is akin to sharing product specs amongst a group so they can compete on features. Lenders can compete on specific line items, but more importantly, they take them to their managers to get their best offer. After sharing them sit back and wait.
Compare all final loan estimates
Run all the rates through any financial analysis you need to.
It will be clear who has the best offer. Afterward, you'll have a transparent document you can share so all competitors know who had the best product and why you chose a specific one.
Due to the transparency and fairness in the process, most lenders appreciate the detail. They might be upset they lost your business, but you can always come back to them in the future.