Sandra Poppema from HippoLogic
12mo ago
The Canadian Clicker Coach: Connecting people with their horses, using positive reinforcement principles ('clicker training'). Hippo = Horse, Logic = Science.
This happens when you expect positive reinforcement (R+) to be similar to or the same as negative reinforcement training (R-).
If you just came across this post, please read part 1, part 2 and part 3 first. Only then does this article make sense.
2 Phases of Negative Reinforcement (R-) Horse Training
Click here to access my previous post, in which I explain this in detail.
5 Phases of Positive Reinforcement (R+) Horse Training
Learn more about phase 4 here.
Phase 5: Stimulus Control (SC) and Other Criteria
SC is fancy jargon to indicate that the horse reliably performs a specific behaviour in response to a distinct cue and does not perform it in the absence of the cue, or in response to other cues.
In this phase, we're crossing the t's in our training.
We train for stimulus control.
3 D's of Advanced Training
We train the 3 D's. This is advanced training.
The first D stands for Duration. We ask our horse to hold up his leg longer.
If we're training walk, trot or canter, we train more than a few steps. We want the horse to keep going until he receives a different cue.
The second D stands for Distractions. This means sprinkling in distractions without losing our horse's attention.
If the behaviour calls for it, we'll practise cueing our horse from a Distance.
We ask our horse to 'stand' while we're walking away to get something. the distance between horse and trainer increases. Often horses want to follow us, so this can be a challenging criterion.
Context Shifts
We train for context shifts, so that the behaviour is strong no matter the environment, or what happens around him.
Trailer loading goes just as well at home, as after a 3-day intentive clinic or after a scary trail ride enountering fireworks and plastic bags.
This phase requires a lot of skill from the trainer!
Novice or sloppy trainers will not reach this level of training, but I believe that anyone can accomplish this phase.
I love teaching this phase to horse owners, because this is the super fancy, very advanced training!
Stimulus Control explained
The horse performs the behavior every time the cue is given: A horse will touch a target every time he hears the word "Target" and not just sometimes.
The horse does not perform the behavior if the cue is not given: A horse will not touch his target, when the target is lying on the ground or when you walk by the pylon. Unless you gave the "Target"-cue.
The horse does not perform the behavior in response to other cues: The horse will not (try to) touch the target when you ask to "Walk on" or cue another behaviour.
The horse does not perform any other behavior when the cue is given: When you say "Target," the horse touches the target gently with his nose, and won't offer a head lowering or tries to kick it with his foot instead.
I think it's very hard to get 100% stimulus control in horses, for all behaviours.
Other species, like dogs are easier to get to this level.
Maybe because we spent more time with our dogs (8-16 hours a day) than our horses (1-2 hours a day, including doing chores, like mucking).
Context Shifts: The Final Phase in Clicker Training
In order to get a reliable horse, we need to train the behaviour in different environments. It's related to the 3rd bullet point under stimulus control.
Horses are really good 'context learners'.
They come and greet you in the pasture, but not when you're holding a halter. They like you, but the halter represents something different...
Your horse is forward under saddle, but without a whip not so much...
The horse loads perfectly every time at home. But after a lesson, when you want to go home it takes an hour to get him in.
You don't understand why your horse doesn't listen! "He knows what to do!" Right?
Wrong!
You haven't trained the behaviour in a different envionment. Horses take the environmental cues seriously. It makes them such good guessers.
We have to practise the behaviour in as much different circumstances and environments as possible.
Until the horse learns to generalize the behaviour.
Generalisation as part of the R+ Training Process
Generalisation is achieved through a gradual process of proofing, where the trainer introduces new variables one at a time. it's important to lower some other criteria when asking the behaviour in a new environment.
For example, start clicking for putting one foot on the loading ramp of the trailer when your loading your horse away from home. This will give him confidence about what to do.
Once a horse has generalized one behaviour, the process will go much faster with other behaviours as well.
Getting Stuck in Phase 5
Usually the expectations of the trainer are way too high. We get disapponted. Frustrated! We think the horse 'knows to get into the trailer' because he does so well at home. We forget to see it from our horse's perspective.
Now the trailer is in a different environment, and the circumstances are different, it is different.
We often forget how much unnatural things we ask from our horse. Self preservation is a highly developed survival behaviour in horses.
When we load our horse during the day, the trailer looks different at night. It's bright inside! At mnight you want to see your surroundings. That's when the predators hunt! No one wants to go into a trap, where escape is not possible.
Similar thing happens on a bright, sunny day.
Inside the trailer it's dark. Horse's eyes (pupils) don't adjust as fasts as human eyes do. So as soon as the horse has his head in the trailer, he experiences it as a dark hole! Scary!
He flies out!
You ask yourself "Why?" It's my own trailer. He's used to it.
Know your Learner! His behaviour, his physiological traits, his learning processes.
Train the behaviour in as much different environments and in as much differents scenario's possible. That's how you get a well-behaviour horse that you can count on.
In every situation.
Even the most unexpected ones. That's the partnership you want to accomplish so you can be safe at all times!