John Vial
3w ago
I Write About Simplifying Robotics For Beginners | PhD In Robotics
AI Coders Generate A New Kind Of Slop For Robotics
Can a low-cost robot turn a valve?
Refineries, ore processing facilities, and any complex chemical plant is going to have thousands of valves. But most of these valves are still hand operated, requiring a human to go out and turn them. If a robot could be sent out instead, it would lower risk and allow these plants to run for longer.
I'm using an AI coding model to build this prototype.
But as the software grew I started finding a new form code slop. My agent knew I was building a robot, it started adding more and more interlocks to ensure "safe" movement. But these interlocks ultimately created a maze of checks and balances.
One day the robot wouldn't even lift an arm.
Even a slight temperature anomaly would trip the safety system. I'm now spending precious time unpicking these checks, trying to convince the coding model that it is safe to so. Trying to remove all this safety slop.
The safest robot is one that doesn't move at all, and it seems this is what my AI coding assistant has built.
John Vial
@johnvial