It’s December 2018 and my family was preparing to buy a larger home.
The mortgage was nearly double our existing mortgage, but I knew we had the cash flow to make it work based on what we were automatically saving through Reverse Budgeting.
Reverse budgeting involves figuring out how much you need to save to meet your goals, then spending everything else as you see fit.
For years I’ve advocated for Reverse Budgeting over tracking expenses, but I panicked when we closed on the new home and began to question the validity of my approach.
I began manually tracking my expenses.
I dusted off my old Excel template from the early years of my career and updated line items (less Bars and Entertainment, more Amazon and Childcare).
Manually tracking expenses is a real chore, but it did give me some useful insights.
#1. Reverse Budgeting Works
It turns out that we could afford the new house. I knew exactly how much we were saving due to reverse budgeting, and using that amount to determine how much house we could afford was effective.
But even though the system works, I had anxiety from having no idea where we spent our money when things felt tight. Perhaps the takeaway here is that reverse budgeting works best during relatively stable life stages.
#2. A High Savings Rate Early In Life Is Key To Flexibility Later In Life
Financial advisors focus a great deal on savings rates as it pertains to retirement planning, but a high savings rate early in life allows for the healthy lifestyle creep that tends to happen in your 30s and 40s.
Whether you’re buying a bigger home, having children, leaving a steady paycheck job to start a business or work for a startup — having the extra cash flow is a sign of living well within your means, which means that a little lifestyle expansion won’t completely derail you.
#3. Spending Categories Change, But Overall Spending Does Not
The categories changed quite a bit since the last time I tracked expenses, but the total spending amount was about the same.
I see this all the time with clients at different stages of life. Most people with kids in college assume they will spend less in retirement, but their spending remains elevated as dollars that were going to tuition are directed to “lets enjoy life” spending.
With retirees, they assume lower spending as they age, but I see their spending remain steady, but shift from travel and leisure to health care and gifting.
#4. Tracking Expenses Creates Awareness and Confidence
For about 20 years now, my weight has never eclipsed a range of 185 to 195 pounds — a fairly healthy weight range given my height (6’2”).
I started counting calories out of curiosity when I got a FitBit many years ago. Since then my weight has typically stayed below 190 pounds when I’m counting calories and above 190 when I’m not.
After many years of data, it doesn’t seem to be a coincidence.
After tracking expense for three years, the same thing seems to hold true. Even when spending does see an uptick, I feel more confident and in control.