Thanks to social media dog parents are inundated with lots of so-called scientific information about their dogs.
If you are skeptical like us, here are three ways to tell the difference between dog science and pseudoscience:
Dog science is rooted in peer-reviewed research.
By peer-reviewed research, we mean that other scientists have looked at the methods and data and have verified that the results are valid. This is the gold standard for any science. For example, when you see a new doggy diet or training fad, and someone talks about what they saw on Tiktok or Instagram, be very wary. And, when in doubt, do a google scholar check to see if the research has been published in a peer-reviewed journal.
Dog science is about citing evidence to back up claims, while pseudoscience is about storytelling and anecdotes.
Unlike pseudoscience, dog science relies on evidence to support claims. When scientists make a claim, they have to back it up with data. Anecdotes (personal stories) are not data. So, if you hear someone say that a certain diet works because it worked for their dog or their friend’s dog, be very skeptical. In order to be considered science, a claim has to be supported by data that can be replicated by other scientists.
Dog science is constantly evolving.
As new research is published, scientists reevaluate their beliefs and theories. They are always trying to find new ways to explain things and will admit when their past assumptions were incorrect. Pseudoscience, on the other hand, is stagnant. The beliefs of pseudoscientists don't change, even when new evidence proves them wrong. So, if you hear someone say that a certain training method is the ONLY way to shape a new behavior in your dog, and they refuse to consider any new evidence, be very skeptical.