First, let's define ethical dog training?
Ethical dog training is using methods that acknowledge that a dog's welfare is not just the absence of suffering, it's positive, affective states - Dr. Valli Fraser-Cellin
So, why is ethical dog training important?
Most dog parents don’t just want obedient dogs, they want happy, healthy, and resilient dogs. Ethical dog training methods can help them get there!
How can you tell that someone is using ethical training methods?
If you follow dog trainers, you’ll learn about terms like force-free, R+, or positive reinforcement. They refer to training methods that don’t cause an aversive experience for the dog. Positive reinforcement, or R+ trainers, don't punish a dog for behaving incorrectly. Instead, they shape and reward the behaviors they do want to see.
Most trainers use positive reinforcement because it is a very powerful tool. But many consider themselves balanced trainers, meaning they use a mix of R+ and aversive methods like prongs and e-collars. As new information and science emerge, more people are reconsidering aversive training methods and seeking out positive reinforcement-only trainers.
If positive reinforcement works, why do people still use punishment in training?
The short answer is that punishment also works. Many people believe that punishment is effective because it works quickly. However, fear and punishment also lead to anxiety. When a dog is distressed there’s a possibility of “shutting down.” A shut-down dog is unresponsive, which could be mistaken for calmness. But the reality is anything but calm, as the dog is experiencing extreme internal stress and anxiety.
💡 Ethical training is based on modern learning theory and our current understanding of animal welfare.
As our understanding of how animals learn and experience the world grows, so too does our responsibility to use the most up-to-date and humane training methods with our furry family members.