Thinking of adopting a dog? Know that breed labels assigned by shelters can influence your selection process!
In February 2014, Orange County Animal Services removed breed assignments from their kennel cards and online adoption profiles. Here is what happened next:
Adoption rates of Pitbulls increased from 52% to 64%
Euthanasia of Pitbulls decreased by 12%
Adoption rates of all other breeds also increased
Why does this matter?
Shelters primarily use physical appearance to assign dogs a breed. Compared to DNA analysis, these assignments are often inaccurate. For example, 50% of dogs labeled as Pitbulls lack the DNA signatures associated with the breed.
Mislabeling dog breeds carries heavy consequences for dogs, especially for dogs labeled as Pitbulls. In shelters, Pitbulls have the lowest adoption rate and highest euthanasia rate. In the parts of United States and throughout the United Kingdom being labeled a Pitbull can be a death sentence.
So what happens if we remove the labels?
Gunter, Barber, and Wynne (2016) worked with shelters in the US to investigate how labels influence potential adopters' perceptions of dogs. They wanted to know what would happen if shelters removed breed labels from their kennels.
They found that:
People associated dogs labeled as “pit-bull-type” as more aggressive and less adoptable compared to look-a-like dogs that appear physically similar.
When the labels were removed, there was no difference in the attractiveness of “pit-bull-type” dogs and their look-a-likes to potential adopters.
Most surprisingly, without labels, potential adopters rated pit-bull-type dogs to be MORE attractive than their look-a-likes in videos!
A dog is more than its breed label. As a potential adopter, you should get to know your dog before you adopt them!
What is their energy level like?
How are they like behaviorally?
Can I see myself caring for this dog for the rest of its life?