Eran Arkin
4y ago
Visit me to learn about Tech Careers, Product Management More. Experienced operator; Beginner online writer. Dad.
I frequently get asked this question. I graduated in 2012 with an MBA from Berkeley, and I believe it's a very subjective question.
Let's start with a Twitter tech myth: "MBA is a waste of time." Silicon Valley loves narratives, particularly the engineer dropout narrative, consider Musk, Page, Brin dropping out from Ph.D. programs, or Zuck drops from undergrad to start a company. It's a prime example of cherry-picking & don't forget that these 'dropouts' had strong networks partly because they were in those institutions in the first place.
It depends
It's not too hard to cherry-pick and find successful MBA entrepreneurs, not to mention executives. Consider Phil Knight (Nike/Stanford), Scott Cook (Intuit/HBS) Scott McNealy (Sun/Stanford). Or top CEOs like Satya Nadella (Chicago), Tim Cook (Duke), and Shantanu Narayen (Adobe/Berkeley), to cherry-pick a few. Even Elon's Tesla CFO holds an MBA. At Google, 5 out of my nine managers throughout the six years were MBAs, and three more had other advanced degrees. But correlation doesn't imply causation.
The truth is there are no right or wrong answers; it depends on your situation, goals, and skill gaps.
For example, in the middle of the great recession, I was a software engineer in Israel. I applied to a US MBA program because I wanted to work in Silicon Valley (screenshot from my essay) and experience top-notch education. There was no way I could work as a product manager at Google in 2012 without an MBA, 5x my pre-MBA salary. It opened the door for me to a US work permit and Google. Other huge benefits were more flexibility with my newly born daughter during school & a lot of fun in a supportive environment with classmates from 30+ countries who are good friends to this day.
Evaluate These First:
What are my career goals? Will MBA help you get there? Especially relevant for those who want to switch industries or geographies.
What is the actual cost of this? Can I get a scholarship? Consider the loss of two years of income & career progression.
How much do I value (additional) lifelong friends? This is one of the most significant benefits of an MBA IMO. In my class alone, we had seven marriages out of 240 students.
Can I realistically get accepted? The potential is bigger in the higher-ranked programs.
The world today is different than it was ten years ago. You can learn & network a ton on LinkedIn, Twitter & YouTube. But spending two years with top-notch classmates & faculty can still be an invaluable experience.