In 2011, I worked for a MAJOR organization and lost the same promotion twice!
Despite being one of the top candidates, achieving my goals and helping all my colleagues. I was told (since you had to self-nominate for consideration) to apply for a newly created position that was also considered a promotion. It was of little interest to me, and I thought it would fail (PS, it did). Then, I applied twice for the promotion I wanted, interviewed twice, and got passed over twice.
It didn't make sense, so I marched into the one office and professionally said, 'WTF'?
Perception is more powerful than reality.
It's not the reality of what you do; it's the perception of what you do that matters.
Upper management felt I wasn't a team player because I didn't heed their advice. Then, I was told in one of my interviews that I was "too confident." I asked another boss if this made sense. He replied, 'Until you do what they want you to do, they will impede every promotion or position and I will deny ever having this conversation.'
They perceived what they wanted to see to validate their actions, so I caved a few months later, just before the president of North America put the kibosh on it (shocker).
It's no longer opinion, it's fact.
Years later, I realized that this was the best advice I ever received.
I pay it forward with a better explanation, especially if I am training teams in client-facing roles. Factors like oral and behavioral language, the listener's past experiences, and unconscious or, worse, conscious biases for people to validate their own agenda play a significant role- whether the perceptions are true or false.
The hard truth is that they do, and that is reality.