How do we persuade someone that their story is wrong?
In Chapter 5 of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow teaches us how to become better listeners.
Listen for three secular plot holes
Secular stories have three plot holes. They cannot explain:
Awe: Our feelings of wonder or the sense of personal significance in such a vast universe.
Origins and Endings: Questions about how life began, our purpose, and life after death.
Morality: Our sense of guilt, justice, good, and evil
Listen for three secular macro-stories
Three big story lines to listen out for are:
The pessimistic secular story. Big bang + evolution = life has no significance. There is no cosmic plan or moral order, and eventually humanity and the world will end.
The optimistic secular story. Reason and science have eliminated the need for religion and enable us to make the world a better place and write a better story by pursuing maximum pleasure and minimal pain for everyone.
The therapeutic spirituality story. God is within and exists to help us find our true potential, feel better, treat others better, and make the world better. We do not need religious books or institutions.
Listen for three secular micro-stories
Although shorter and smaller, these micro stories often take over our lives:
Consumerism. The good life comes through what you buy
Achievement: The good life comes through achievement and success.
Romance. The good life comes through finding our true love.
How do we persuade someone that their story is wrong? Persuasion starts by becoming a better listener.