David Murray
/davidpmurray
Changing stories with God's Story through sermons, books, and podcasts. Pastor, Author, Professor, PhD. Daily podcasts @ www.thestorychanger.life
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
Christian and non-Christian agree, finding love is the most important part of being human? But what does love mean and how do we find it? We are not at all agreed on that, as chapter 7 of Telling a Better Story explains.
INSIDE THE SECULAR STORY
The scientific secular story says we are simply the result of natural processes, and therefore love is either a chemical reaction or a survival mechanism.
The cultural narrative of achievement views love as a transaction that we pay into, in the hope of getting more out of it.
The self-actualization story which ties human flourishing to self-expression views others as simply an instrument to help our self-actualization.
All these stories base love upon self-interest, raising big questions:
Can self-interest and survival of the fittest be the foundation for loving relationships?
Can we rest in another’s love as a gift if we feel we have to earn it?
Is this ‘love’ sufficient to keep people together through tough times, times when people are not advancing our self-actualization?
OUTSIDE TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
Although secular people often live self-sacrificial rather than self-interested lives, in doing so they are living consistently with the Christian story, not their own secular story.
Love is essential to God as an eternal communion of self-giving love.
Made in the image of a self-giving God, we are designed to lovingly give ourselves to others.
In the ultimate act of self-giving love, God gave himself as a sacrifice for sin, to secure our love for him and others.
Resting in God’s love changes us and our love, and living out this love through personal sacrifice is the only way to discover our true selves.
What does love mean and how do we find it? Find the basis, meaning, and resources for love in the Christian story of self-fulfillment through self-denial.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
'Social justice' originated in Christian thought and flowed out of the belief in divine justice. Today, 'social justice' is widely used by people who do not believe in God, never mind divine justice. Can you have human justice without divine justice? Can you have social justice without spiritual justice? Chapter 7 of Telling a Better Story says "No."
INSIDE THE SECULAR STORY
The secular story of justice can be summed up in two sentences.
Unbelievers have a strong sense of justice and a strong desire for a just society.
Social justice is grounded in two foundational assumptions: everyone has the same basic human dignity and we all should love everyone.
While appreciating and commending people’s sense of justice, opposition to injustice, and love for others, we have questions for their narrative:
What grounds do you have to affirm basic human dignity and our obligation to care for others? Neither nature nor self-interest can support them.
What can motivate you to act justly and with high moral standards when it involves self-sacrifice?
What is your ultimate hope of removing injustice given it's impossible here?
OUTSIDE TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
Christians have a better grounding for justice, in that God made us in his image with a sense of right and wrong.
Christians have a powerful motivation in Jesus' example of self-sacrifice, God's unchanging standard of justice, and God's love for the world.
Christians have a better hope of social, indeed universal justice, because God will usher in perfect justice and offers to put you on the right side of justice through faith in Jesus.
Can you have human justice without divine justice? Only a justice grounded in God, motivated by God, and that hopes in God will change our world for good.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
How much are you worth? What dollar figure would you put on your value? Everyone wants to be highly valued, to feel that they are worth a lot. How is that calculated?
In Chapter 7 of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow guides us from a false to a true valuation.
INSIDE THE SECULAR STORY
The secular narrative of value is:
We find our value by looking outside of ourselves (as advertisers know)
Our value increases if we have the same sports shoe as LeBron James, the same body as Kim Kardashian, the same car, house, watch, job, success, followers, friends, etc., as (fill in the gap).
If we can increase our value we’ll increase our happiness.
Questions to ask this story
What is your present value and how did you arrive at that figure?
What or who is your valuer or validator and how do their opinions/views/validation impact you?
How accurate/steady/secure is their valuation?
What if you lose your job, health, marriage, hero, etc?
OUTSIDE TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
We can now point people to the Christian story.
We get our value from God who made us in his image, redeems us through his Son, and lives in us by his Spirit.
Our worth is derived from God’s creative hands, Christ’s bleeding hands, and the Spirit’s ever-present hands.
Other people and things are not our source of worth but good gifts from God for us to enjoy for a time.
How much are you worth? Get your worth from God for the highest, safest, and happiest value.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
Ever heard of ‘Sheilaism’? No, neither had I until I read chapter 7 of Telling a Better Story by Josh Chatrow. It’s how a young nurse called Sheila describes her religion. “It’s Sheilaism. Just my own little voice.”
In defining what she calls “my own Sheilaism,” she said: “It’s just try to love yourself and be gentle with yourself. You know, I guess, take care of each other. I think [God] would want us to take care of each other.”
Like many today, Sheila has answered the question “Where do I find truth?” by turning inwards rather than upwards, inside rather than outside. Let’s get inside her story and see if we can lead her to a better story.
INSIDE THE SECULAR STORY
My ultimate guide is my feelings and everyone (God too), must submit to that.
Any external authority is dangerous, oppressive, and takes away my personhood.
Being true to myself, being unique and authentic, is the highest good.
Questions to ask this story:
Does this story provide one of the most basic human needs of a stable identity?
Can anyone be truly independent? Are we not all shaped by external norms?
What happens when two people’s feelings/truths collide?
OUTSIDE TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
The Christian story is so much more satisfying and successful:
Truth is external, divine, objective, universal, and unchanging.
Submitting to God and his truth is the safest and best way to individual and community flourishing in every area of life (including our feelings).
God gives us value, significance, identity, validation, and worth in Jesus Christ that no one and nothing can add to or take away.
Where do I find truth? Find truth in God for a safe and secure guide, identity, meaning, and worth.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
Everyone loves a love-story. No one loves a death-story. Yet we all have two death-stories.
The first is the one God wrote about how and when we will die, a death-story we cannot know and cannot change. The second is the story we tell ourselves about death, a story we can know and change.
What's your death story? In Chapter 6 of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow identifies some of the stories that secular people tell themselves about death.
INSIDE THE SECULAR STORY
The four most common secular narratives about death are:
The denial narrative. Ignore it and hope it goes away.
'The End' narrative. Death is the end of our story. Therefore live life to the full.
The fantasy narrative. We’re all going to a better place, so don't worry about it.
The despair narrative. Death renders everything about this life meaningless.
Questions to ask this narrative include:
How’s your denial of death going? Is it going away?
If death is the end, how can this life have any meaning?
Who decides if we’re all going to a better place and how?
Would you not prefer a better story of death and therefore also of life?
OUTSIDE TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
The Christian story about death is so much better:
Death results from sin, both of which are invaders of God’s perfect creation
God sent his Son to die, defeat death, and rise again so that his people can die, defeat death, and rise again.
Death doesn't separate us from Christ’s love but ushers us into his eternal love and life.
Life and death are packed full of significance and meaning
Unbelievers will die again and again and again forever.
What’s your death story? Accept God's death-story to have a love-story.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
What do you find beautiful? For me it's a salmon or a steelhead in my net. For others it may be a song or a baby or Mozart or a painting.
How does beauty affect us? It arrests us and stops us in our tracks. It widens our eyes and opens our mouths. It amazes us, stuns us, and moves us.
But have you ever wondered where that sense of beauty comes from? How is beauty beautiful? In Chapter 6 of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow answers this question using 'Story Apologetics' or 'Inside-Out Apologetics.'
INSIDE THE SECULAR STORY
The secular story about beauty and our sense of beauty is:
They're just a by-product of evolutionary history that helps mating
Beauty is just a chance collection of atoms, and our sense of beauty is just the product of uncontrollable brain neutrons. Neither point to anything higher or deeper.
Questions to ask this narrative include:
Can you find something beautiful if it's just an accident?
Is our wife or child still beautiful if just a random collection of atoms.
Are acts of charity beautiful if they're the result of chance and natural selection
Can this story explain our longing for beauty.
OUTSIDE TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
Beauty exists because God is beautiful and all that is beautiful is from him.
God created everything beautiful and the perfect sense of what is beautiful.
Sin has ruined much beauty and damaged our sense of beauty.
The remaining beauty points to God.
The longing for beauty is a longing for God and for him to re-create everything beautiful.
Christians create beauty to point to our beautiful creative God.
Creating and admiring beauty are ways to worship God.
How is beauty beautiful? Find beauty in our beautiful God and expose his beauty by worshiping him and beautifying his world in our callings.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
“I want my life to count.” That longing is deep inside all of us, isn’t it? But how? How do we find meaning and significance? In Chapter 6 of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow answers this question using 'Story Apologetics' or 'Inside-Out Apologetics.'
GETTING INSIDE SECULAR STORIES
The secular story about meaning is:
The world has no divine, transcendent, or eternal significance.
We have a personal sense of significance which can be satisfied with relationships, experiences, possessions, and successes (REPS).
Even if achieved, these things do not satisfy our quest for significance, leaving a restless sense of something is missing and a longing for something more.
Some double down and try to get more REPS or better REPS while others despair and give up on finding personal meaning altogether.
Questions to ask this narrative include:
Can your story explain the sense that life has a purpose and your life is meaningful?
Can you explain where this sense of meaning comes from, if matter is all there is, if everything began with a big bang and will end with a big bang?
Is it possible that the something missing cannot be found in this world and would you consider looking at another story?
POINTING OUT TO THE CHRISTIAN STORY
Live out the Christian story of meaning, then tell the true story of meaning.
God's hardwired us to live for a purpose because we are made in his image.
Sin thwarts our story of meaning because it redirects us away from God and ultimately ends our stories and everything in them.
Through Jesus Christ, God rescues us from sinful futility, gives us a reason to live, and promises eternal significance.
Jesus is the model of living with purpose and an eternal goal.
How do we find meaning? Find satisfying meaning in God’s redemptive story for the world and for us, as modeled by Jesus.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
In writing the book, The StoryChanger, I read many books about how to tell better stories. Josh Chatrow’s book, Telling a Better Story, was one of them but it’s uniquely focused on how to tell God’s Story better.
It's there that we run into a major problem: few people are anxiously waiting for us to tell God's Story and others have rejected it. So how do I start a conversation about God? Let's visit the garage.
We have story-engines
The stories the world is telling people are so loud that we can’t cut through the noise. Some have been listening to these stories for so long that they don’t even notice their influence upon them.
As Chatrow says, lives are powered by story-engines but most drive without thinking about what‘s happening under the hood.
To be convinced that we must repair our car, we need a mechanic to explain what's wrong, why we need to fix it, and what benefits the fix will bring.
We are story-mechanics
Chatrow trains us to become story-mechanics that explain what’s going on under the hood, and how the Gospel story can repair what’s broken.
Take the great question of life’s meaning. How do we get inside people's engines and show what’s going wrong with their significance cylinder?
It all begins with being a living apologetic, says Chatrow, by modeling the meaning of life, especially as we drive through suffering and sorrow. Then non-Christians will see how we find meaning and significance even on the hardest roads.
That's a living apologetic that will open the door to story apologetics when they run into their own life-storms and ask for “the reason for the hope that you have” (1 Peter 3:15).
How do I start a conversation about God? Live out God's story and you'll get a chance to speak God's Story.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
Every month, I sit in the barber’s chair and, unknown to the hairdresser, there’s an unseen mental battle going on in my mind just millimeters from her scissors as I wrestle with the question "How can I share the Gospel?” Many times I’ve left with less hair but more guilt because I just don’t know where or how to start.
Josh Chatrow has given me new hope in his book Telling A Better Story: How To talk About God In A Skeptical Age and his method of 'Inside-Out' apologetics.
Inside: Enter the person’s story and ask these two questions.
What can I affirm, and what will I need to challenge?
Study the culture’s stories and their personal stories identifying the areas that overlap with the Christian story and those that contradict it.
Where does this story lead, and is it internally consistent and livable?
Sow uncertainty by asking questions that show how their stories are simplistic, inconsistent or unlivable.
Outside: Point the way out to the Christian story with these two questions.
Where do competing views borrow from the Christian story?
Even some atheists admit that many of their values are copied or borrowed from religious ideas.
“Though your secular friends may oppose Christianity, in many ways it is still pumping through their veins and directly linked to what they see as a healthy society.” Josh Chatrow.
2. How does the Christian narrative better address our experiences, observations, and history?
This four question framework is designed to create space for others to reflect whether Christianity offers a better story. Hopefully it won't result in my remaining hair being shaved off.
How can I share the Gospel? Question secular stories from the inside to point out to the scriptural story.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
I’ve read (or tried to read) many books about apologetics. Most of them have left me asking, “But who talks like that?”
So much of Christian apologetics is detached from reality. It’s academics speaking to academics, but it’s utterly useless for everyday conversations. Is there a more useable and useful apologetics?
In chapter five of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow contrasts traditional apologetics with story apologetics.
Traditional Apologetics
This model of apologetics has four building blocks.
1. The foundation is a shared logical and rational framework
2. Argue for general theism.
3. The historical evidence for Bible’s reliability
4. The capstone is sharing the Gospel
Chatrow’s critiques of this model includes:
It doesn’t foster two-way conversations
The Gospel comes at the end
It has a mechanical step-by-step feel
“Stringing together premises and conclusions is not most people’s idea of an engaging conversation.”
Story Apologetics
This model has six circles in a circle. The first three circles are the three big stories in our culture: the pessimistic secular story, the optimistic secular story, and the moral therapeutic spirituality story (aka my feelings are god). The next three circles are the three smaller stories in individual lives: the stories of romance, consumerism, and achievement.
At the center of these six circles is the Gospel story we continually compare and contrast with the culture’s and the individual’s story. The advantages of story apologetics are:
It is more circular and conversational
The Gospel is central and woven into the conversation
It emphasizes the importance of listening
It identifies overlaps and connecting points
It uses logic, evidence, history, etc., but not as a framework.
Is there a more useable and useful apologetics? Story apologetics is useable by everyday Christians and useful for everyday non-Christians.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
Apologetics, the defense of the faith, is something only experts do, right? Even the word ‘apologetics’ says “Keep out: Experts only.” Apologetics books do the same. How can someone ordinary like me do apologetics?
One of the reasons I like Josh Chatrow’s book, Telling a Better Story, is that by focusing on stories, it makes apologetics accessible to all, and do-able by all. In chapter 5, for example, he sums it up as steeping in and stepping into.
Steep your life in the Gospel Story
All our stories have been edited or even taken over by the culture. That’s why Chatrow says we must begin by embedding our lives in the true story, the Gospel story.
“Constantly comparing the rival stories to God’s story is essential to not being lulled to sleep in a secular age.”
Studying Christ’s story will not just challenge and change our story, it will challenge and change our character, an essential element of any apologetic or evangelistic witness. That way we not only tell a different story, we are a different story.
Step into others’ stories
The next step, Chatrow says, is to learn how to step into others stories in order to point them to the way out. He calls this “inside-out” apologetics and it involves six stages:
Listen for their stories (big and small narratives that shape their lives)
Highlight inconsistencies within their story
Identify overlaps with the Christian story
Discuss disagreements with the Christian story
Explore how satisfied they are with their story
Try on the Christian story to see how it fits them and the world
That’s doable apologetics isn’t it? Apologetics for dummies, even!
How can I do apologetics? Steep in the Gospel story and step into others stories in order to help them step out and into Christ’s story.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
How do we persuade someone that their story is wrong?
In Chapter 5 of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow teaches us how to become better listeners.
Listen for three secular plot holes
Secular stories have three plot holes. They cannot explain:
Awe: Our feelings of wonder or the sense of personal significance in such a vast universe.
Origins and Endings: Questions about how life began, our purpose, and life after death.
Morality: Our sense of guilt, justice, good, and evil
Listen for three secular macro-stories
Three big story lines to listen out for are:
The pessimistic secular story. Big bang + evolution = life has no significance. There is no cosmic plan or moral order, and eventually humanity and the world will end.
The optimistic secular story. Reason and science have eliminated the need for religion and enable us to make the world a better place and write a better story by pursuing maximum pleasure and minimal pain for everyone.
The therapeutic spirituality story. God is within and exists to help us find our true potential, feel better, treat others better, and make the world better. We do not need religious books or institutions.
Listen for three secular micro-stories
Although shorter and smaller, these micro stories often take over our lives:
Consumerism. The good life comes through what you buy
Achievement: The good life comes through achievement and success.
Romance. The good life comes through finding our true love.
How do we persuade someone that their story is wrong? Persuasion starts by becoming a better listener.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
What’s the best argument for Christianity?
Although apologists are often asked that question, it is the wrong question.
Relationship before Reason
Witnessing involves logic, evidences, truth, philosophy, etc., but the best witness is grounded in human connection and relationship not winning an argument.
In chapter four of Telling a Better Story, Josh Chatrow calls us to prioritize relationship over reason. He reminds us that we are fundamentally emotional beings made to love and be loved, made to relate to God and others through stories.
We can have all the facts and information in the world but if we are cold, impersonal, robotic, then people will just dismiss us and our words.
Stories before arguments
Arguments and logic do not capture the heart. Compelling stories do because, “The human mind is a story processor, not a logic processor.” God made us to love and to connect through stories and connects with us through a book of stories within a grand narrative.
But the biblical story is up against strong competing storylines in our culture that are capturing hearts. Netflix, Spotify, commercials, etc., are all storytellers that are snagging hearts and writing their story about life and history in billions of minds every day.
As Chatrow puts it, “Everyone believes a story about their life and about history itself.” It’s just a question of which story.
What’s the best argument for Christianity? Rather ask, what’s the best story for Christianity and become a better story-teller not a better arguer.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
How can I witness better to non-Christians?
Which Christian hasn’t asked that? We miss opportunities and mess up opportunities to tell people about Jesus.
One reason we mess up is that Christians are living on two stories in a one-story world (think building levels not books). That’s how Josh Chatrow puts it in chapter three of Telling a Better Story.
The Old Two-Story World
For most of human history, people lived in a two-story world. They believed that humans lived on the first floor and the divine lived on the second floor but also visited the first floor, set the rules for the first floor, influenced the first floor, and offered the opportunity to come to the second floor when people died.
Evangelism therefore focused on who the divine being was, how to get on the right side of him, and how to get to the second floor.
The New One-Story World
Most people today live in a one-story world. For them, there is no second floor and therefore no divine being. The first floor is all there is and all there is to live for. Yet, deep down, people know something is missing. They know there’s more to life than this and there is life after this.
Evangelism today has to cultivate that sense of something is missing, help people rebuild the second story, point to who lives there, and who has come to the first floor to invite us to join him on the second.
How can I witness better to non-Christians? Help them to rebuild the second story.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
If you’ve ever had concussion, you’ll know how it leaves you confused, disoriented, overwhelmed, dazed, and disconnected from the world around us.
Josh Chatrow believes most Christians are suffering with ‘cultural concussion.' Waking up in a world we no longer recognize, we're left confused, disoriented, overwhelmed, intimidated, and disconnected from the world around us.
How do we recover from cultural concussion?
In Chapter 3 of Telling a Better Story, Chatrow starts to clear our heads by identifying three stories, understanding the cultural narrative, and comparing stories
Distinguish three stories
The cultural narrative people have been born into and that defines them.
Individual’s stories, which are more varied than they ever were.
Our own personal and cultural stories and how they’ve shaped us
Understand the cultural narrative
Tradition and religion have been abandoned in favor of science and reason.
Family and community have been replaced by the individual
Skepticism trumps faith
Personal Autonomy and freedom is the ultimate value
Comparing Stories
No story line can be proven, but they can be compared to see:
Does this story make sense of the data? Is it consistent?
Is it livable? Does it match observation and experience?
How much faith is required to believe this story?
How does a person’s current script compare with the Christian story?
How do we recover from cultural concussion? Understand the cultural story, the individual’s story, and our own story so that we can ask the right questions as we compare and contrast stories.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
How do we interest people in the story of Christ?
We don’t have to. They already are interested. It’s just that they don’t realize it! That's what Josh Chatrow argues in chapter two of Telling a Better Story: How to Talk about God in a Skeptical Age.
God’s Story is Inescapable
When it comes to the Gospel story, some don’t know it, some suppress it, some reject it, and some oppose it. However, the ignorant, the suppressors, the rejecters, and the opposers, cannot escape it.
The most popular stories in our culture are stories of guilt, sacrifice, redemption, resurrection, and a world beyond this. Echoes of the Christian story continue to influence the stories of our modern age, as even J. K. Rowling has admitted.
God’s Story is Imaged in us
Why is story so much part of us? Why can’t we shake off God’s Story?
It’s because God, the Master Storyteller, made us in his image, and therefore designed us as storytellers telling mini-stories that are shadows of the Greatest Story.
In J R Tolkien’s words, we are ‘sub-creators’ subconsciously mirroring our Creator and even echoing the “supreme” story that “entered History.” The divine narrative is embedded within us.
The Christian story therefore connects with our stories, explains our stories, corrects our stories, completes our stories, and gives us a better story about stories.
How do we interest people in the story of Christ? As divine image-bearers, they cannot escape it, therefore take every opportunity to highlight Christ's story in the culture's stories.
David Murray
Story Apologetics
4y ago
Apologetics, the defense of the Christian faith, was my least favorite subject at Seminary. Its philosophical and scientific approach left me bored and cold.
Is there a Christian apologetic that's relevant, beautiful, and compelling?
Josh Chatrow, a practicing apologist in Raleigh, NC, has answered with Telling a Better Story: How to Talk about God in a Skeptical Age. Here’s a summary what I learned from the introduction and the first chapter.
Christianity was the old story. The Christian story used to be part of our national story with daily life assuming God created the world, gave us a purpose, imposed morals, promised judgment, and offered salvation. This was the background story to every other story.
Other stories have replaced the Christian story. That story is not only rejected, but critiqued as false and oppressive, and other rival cultural narratives have taken its place. Despite the new anti-story gods of science, rationalism, and technology, as Netflix proves, there is still a deep human longing for life-explaining stories. Therefore, stories are the way into people’s lives and a bridge to sharing God’s story.
Christians need to be better storytellers. Given the changed circumstances, we need better story-telling skills to persuade people that the best location for their story is inside God’s Story.
Christians and non-Christians need this. Apologetics does not just persuade unbelievers but also assures doubting believers by engaging their stories respectfully and inviting them to consider a better story.
Is there a Christian apologetic that's relevant, beautiful, and compelling? Josh Chatrow answers: Yes, story-based apologetics can be relevant, beautiful, and compelling.