Laura McInerney
4y ago
Co-Founder of Teacher Tapp, the influential daily survey app. Recovering education journalist: former editor of @SchoolsWeek and @Guardian columnist.
25 years ago New Labour were elected into power.
Ten weeks later they brought forward a HUGE White Paper, Excellence in Schools, covering all parts of school reform.
I've read back over it today & it's quite something!
So, what did it say & what can we learn from it? 🧵...
Excellence in Schools opens by noting the government's worry that too many kids were in schools that weren't delivering enough for their kids.
To solve it the government wanted to provide two things:
Unrelenting pressure to improve, AND
Unrelenting support to help do it
Nowadays, politicians say this sort stuff all the time but there are often few policies behind.
But in 1997 the Labour Party seriously meant business. And boy, did they have plans to back up that intention. HOLD ON TO YOUR HATS. Here is just some of their white paper policies...
1 - A MAX class size of 30 for children aged 7 or below. < At the time this was radical. I'd been in a class of 42 myself and seen how horrible it was. Given the importance of a good start at school, Labour promised this and went hell-for-leather to deliver it.
2 - They published NATIONAL targets:
80% 11 year olds to achieve 'expected standard' in English
75% to achieve expected standard in maths
How?
Getting each school to devote a structured hour a day to literacy
Creating a numeracy task force to create a similar programme
3 - A Whole School Improvement Infrastructure:
DfE set national targets
LEAs checked on school data against targets
Ofsted checked on quality of what was happening in schools
Schools delivered on the targets
4 - LEAs were to have a range of options if schools were underperforming:
offer support
Give a formal warning, requesting a plan of action from the school
invite OFSTED to inspect the school
appoint additional governors
withdraw budget delegation from the school.
5 - In return, LEAs had to send off plans to Sec of State every 3 years and if they that DIDN'T do their role properly the gov could intervene.
It was complex, (and didn't always work as planned) but the ambition and detail is there!
6 - There's a whole section on Ofsted but the cutest bit is that they want reform the "period of notice of inspection from FIVE TERMS to TWO TERMS, with a firm date for the inspection arranged one or one and a half terms in advance" < Oh how we all laugh at this now.
7 - Labour committed to strengthening the complains and appeals process against Ofsted inspections. (The current Labour Party might want to look at this again!)
8 - Gifted & Talented < There's A whole section on identifying and supporting "particularly able and talented children". Given the party was stopping private school subsidies & banning more grammar schools, this balanced the 'but what about clever kid' questions.
9 - Specialist schools! Anyone who went to a 'ICT specialist' or 'language school' int he 2000s will remember this. The aim was to have 'families' of schools with expertise that could be shared. The idealism in the policy is palpable.
10 - A National Grid For Learning.
1997 was early internet days but there are promises to connect up schools to the internet, build online educational content and train teachers in ICT.
11 - Fast-track headship routes and a mandatory headship qualification
PLUS using the best headteachers to mentor other headteachers across the country.
12 - On teaching, there was also:
New teacher standards
Introduction of the induction year for NQTs, AND
Building a virtual teaching college! (I don't think this last one actually happened?)
13 - Introducing a highly-paid Advanced Skills Teacher role to help keep people in the classroom.
Establish a General Teaching Council to regulate teachers independent of government.
Remove admin tasks from teachers (e.g. making wall displays).
14 - How is this still going?!
I've not even got to:
Upskilling teaching assisntants
Introducing home-school learning contracts
Laying out national homework guidelines
Stopping 16 year olds leaving at Easter
Food standards
Citizenship teaching etc etc
Ultimately, some of it worked and some didn't. But what it is a good reminder of is AMBITION.
In 1997 New Labour wanted to improve education from top to bottom and they weren't afraid to commit resources or energy to it. The current white paper pales in comparison.
BUT, THE BIG QUESTION IS: Do we want this sort of big ambition for the next 20 years in education? Or something quieter? And do we think any of the parties will deliver something solid?
At the min, I'm not holding out great hope.