Laura McInerney
/lauramcinerney
Co-Founder of Teacher Tapp, the influential daily survey app. Recovering education journalist: former editor of @SchoolsWeek and @Guardian columnist.
Laura McInerney
3y ago
Last weekend we asked the 9,000 teachers on @TeacherTapp about the kindest thing a pupil or colleague had done in the past half-term.
3,285 of you responded and by response 647 I was in tears. You people are lovely ❤️
Here's a thread of, well, loads of them... 🧵 (Grab tissues)
18 more posts
Laura McInerney
4y ago
There's a teacher shortage coming. It's been coming for a while, but was staved off slightly by the pandemic. Now, it's heaving back into view and the sight isn't pretty.
The first thing to say is that retention also matters. But teachers have always left the profession at fairly high rates in their first few years in the job. And the government really is trying to deal with this via the new Early Career support deal. They may not succeed, but they are trying.
Furthermore, given the likely coming recession, we probably aren't going to see lots of teachers junking their jobs. Hence, while it would be good to keep more people in teaching, that's for a separate article.
The real-and-pressing issue is that we may not be able to hire enough teachers into the profession in the first place.
As Sam Freedman wrote in TES this week, the teacher trainee recruitment figures are grim:
Only 15% of physics teachers are likely to be hired
Every subject bar drama, PE, history & classics will miss their targets too
We are down 10% on 2019, and that was a tough year.
Sam goes on to mention pay and he's right; teaching is not particularly competitive for new graduates. The government is therefore hiking starting salaries to £30k.
But even this may not solve our woes. Plus it definitely isn't going to deal with the gaping non-teaching staff shortage that schools are also facing down.
The truth is that we have some big non-education issues affecting school recruitment that no one is really talking about.
Let me change that now.
1. There are weirdly few 21-year-olds
England is at the nadir of a baby bust. In the year 2000s, for reasons I haven't yet figured out very few people were having children.
In the year 2000, only around 670,000 children were born. The only time in the UK's history where it was lower was 1977. By 2012 it was back up to 807,000. (It is now 715,000).
Not only is this bad news because of the low number of young adults coming into the labour market, it also means the number of children in schools - and especially about to enter primary schools - is very large.
That is doubly bad. At the precise moment when we need more secondary teachers there are fewer people joining the adult workforce.
The only upside is that, in ten years' time, we are likely to have fewer kids in schools and loads of adults entering the workforce. So at least this problem isn't eternal.
2. Graduate employers really want to hire women.
Since 2018 large employers have published their equal pay audits, as required under law. For many companies the results were embarrassing.
A major problem is that many companies didn't hire equal numbers of men and women onto their graduate schemes. Back in 2015 the figures were 60:40 to the men. Add to this imbalance the fact that women historically dropped out of labour markets at higher rate due to childbirth and many companies had heavily male executives. Awks.
So, rightly, graduate recruiters have tried even things up. In a bid to increase diversity, there is an unspoken preference in many places to have slightly more women start in a cohort so that things are more balanced later down the line.
Unfortunately, schools also rely on a female workforce. Last time I looked 85% of primary teachers were female and 62% in secondary schools.
Hence, not only are there fewer young adults in the labour market this year, the big employers - with deep pockets and great work-life incentives - are also coming for the same ones that schools usually recruit.
3. Oh, and the rest of the world wants our teachers too.
Before the pandemic British Schools abroad were growing like knotweed.
Back then the estimate was that international school numbers would double by 2029, increasing the need for teachers from 500,000 (at present) to 916,900. That's almost the entire teaching profession in the UK.
Things slowed a little but those schools will be recruiting again now.
And while teachers in those schools could come from all over the world, British international schools make up 43% of the sector, and there is a premium on native-speaker teachers, which means England's teachers are particularly attractive.
Going to teach abroad is also attractive to many teachers, especially younger ones. Lower taxes and subsidised accommodation makes a big difference to graduates who might otherwise pay sky-high rents, especially in the south of England.
So we have a perfect storm:
Fewer young adults right when we have lots of pupils
Graduate employers going after our core market
International schools also wanting in too
But there's an even BIGGER elephant in the room that we need to address.
One which also affects retention of teachers, as well as non-teaching staff, especially learning support assistants.
The truth is that for the past forever, schools have run off the backs of women who accepted poorly-paid termtime-only jobs because they needed to finish earlier and have school holidays to look after their kids.
That group are now disappearing.
A plethora of work-from-home jobs mean that women who once took minimum wage jobs as teaching assistants can now work flexibly as online sales people, virtual receptionists, social media schedulers, any number of online opportunities all around the world.
They can work while the kids are at school and again when they are in bed. They can log on in the holidays, while their kids are playing Roblox, and keep earning.
Realistically, the ability to work from home in other jobs will also influence some teacher's thinking too. Schools that could rely on being the highest paid graduate job in the area now have to deal with professions becoming remotely available.
However, many teachers come into the job because they love the thrill of the classroom and working with young people - and they are likely to still stay.
For support staff, however, who chose the job because it was the most flexible option available, it's a no-brainer to switch.
Schools are therefore heading into a staffing squeeze, much of which isn't to do with the environment of schools - and it will get worse before it gets better.
What are the solutions? That's for a future blog. But I'd be very happy to hear suggestions and innovations that you've seen or thought of, so please do let me know!
Laura McInerney
4y ago
BEHOLD: It is the greatest day in the stamp collecting calendar!
It is the start of the EUROPA STAMP COMPETITION.
Think: Eurovision. But instead of 🎤 it's STAMPS 🤗
How does it work?
Since 1956, countries across Europe have co-ordinated one set of stamps per year.
Originally they all used the same design, but by the '70s they came up with a better idea: Have A Theme!
Since then, each year, the Europa committee picks a theme and then each country represents it on one of their stamps.
The first theme was SCULPTURES and Luxembourg entered this sexy beast to show off its modern ways. (Most others were boring religious ones).
A few years later, 1976, HANDICRAFT was the theme. Which meant a lot of countries cracked out their best set of jugs. (Easy - this is stamp collecting!)
E.g. this lovely lot from the Isle of Man
Or my personal fave from that year - MALTA.
I love the sheer WE WILL BE ARTISTIC of these stamps.
Also: kudos for the gender balance, which stamps are historically rubbish at.
NB: If you're wondering why I haven't mentioned Britain so far, it's because we are 😬 about Europa.
Sadly, all stamps must include the word 'Europa'.
Britain uniquely doesn't write its name on stamps as we created them.
So we HATE writing Europa!
Nonetheless, Europa stamps became a huge collectors item and in 2002 PostEurop had a brainwave:
Why not make it a contest?!
So, each year, the stamps are gathered together and YOU CAN VOTE ONLINE FOR YOUR FAVE: https://www.posteurop.org/europa2022
This year's Europa theme is 'Stories & Myths', which is ace, because you get lovely images AND the stories behind them.
Eg. the FAROE ISLANDS entry depicts a pig suffering perpetual immaculate inceptions until it's drowned by keys on its tale and turned into an island. Obvs.
OR, there's FRANCE's entry which shows Melusina: who appears to be a sort of dragony mermaid, that variously lives in caves, the sea and the moors.
(I really feel the French couldn't be bothered to come up with lots of bedtime stories).
And then there's PORTUGAL, doing its usual religious thing, with a story about a man, some fog and the Lady of Nazareth.
As ever, my fave this year is Azerbaijan, who have had my vote for the last five years and yet never win. 😭
GO CHECK IT OUT & vote for your favourite too! https://www.posteurop.org/europa2022
& if you'd like to read more about Europa & see a list of former winners > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_postage_stamp
Laura McInerney
4y ago
The media has been fired up today at the idea exams might go online in the future!
It isn't likely to happen anytime soon. BUT here are FOUR reasons why I think Ofqual *should* be pushing to make it happen... 🧵
1. Paper exams are bad for the environment! 🌳
Around 1.2m young people sit GCSEs & A-Levels each year. Most do multiple subjects, across multiple papers. Which involves exam boards printing and couriering around hundreds of millions of pages.
2. No more guessing which paper a kid has to sit.
Because the range of abilities at GCSEs is broad, a single exam paper often can't cover the entire grade range, so students are entered either for a lower or higher paper. It's a gamble that could stop with online exams...
... because adaptive exams would be able to start with a question, and if the student can't answer it, the computer moves to an easier one. If the student CAN answer it, the computer goes to a harder question. Hence reducing the guesswork involved in tiering.
3. It more obviously reflects the workplace. Seriously, when was the last time you handwrote an essay? https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/dec/19/santa-email-students-exams-pen-handwriting
4. Finally - and this is just my dream rather than something anyone might aim for - I hope that it would make resits easier. One of the major problems with our exam system is it's mainly 'one shot and done'. Only maths & English GCSE differ and even that has issues.
Suppose online exams could run at repeated points across the year. That could be life-changing for young people who suffer a last-minute challenge before exams (see below) and for older workers needing qualifications for a career change.
HENCE, it won't be easy to move exams online. But I think it's the right thing for us, as a country, to investigate - and I hope it can be used to make exams more flexible, especially in lifelong learning.
Laura McInerney
4y ago
#1 Write (or say) a lot. Publicly.
A nice thing about journalism is that you can do it without anyone’s permission. There is no licence. No required qualification. Get yourself a free blog. Get on YouTube. Twitter. Tiktok. Just start saying things. The more you write or present to camera, the more feedback you will get, the more you can try to adapt and the better you will get.
If you write for an hour a week, then at the end of the year you will only have done 52 hours of practice. But that’s 52 hours more than you did last year, and 51 hours more than a person who knocked out a single blog and now is sitting around wondering why someone didn’t turn them into a journalist yet. Just think: if they do 1 hour and you do 52, you will be 52 times more experienced than them. That’s just in one year. Do an hour a day and you just 365-timesed your experience.
#2 Get a niche
Journalism jobs come in all shapes and sizes, so it’s a good idea to stay flexible. m
BUT there is a lot to be said for having at least one niche – even if you only write about it for free in your spare time. A niche makes you memorable.
With my own writing, I initially wrote a lot about education politics back when I was a secondary school teacher. A friend who was starting a thinktank needed content for his site and asked me to do a fortnightly blog based on current education news. I did that for two years. Then, I took a break from teaching to study in the US. While there, I woke up at 3am every Tuesday to watch the Education Select Committee back in the UK, and would both live-tweet the committee. I did that for another two years. Gradually, I became known as the education policy lady. The one who knows about free schools. Or funding. Then I became the “education expert”. These days, if the BBC or ITV want someone to come on and explain an education issue, they come to me. It took about ten years to get to this point.
So start your niche, and start soon.
#3 Read books about journalism
Here’s a secret: most journalists don’t take their professional learning as seriously as you. m As a journalist, if I asked for recommendations of books that would teach me how to be a better journalist, people mostly laughed and offered fictional accounts of newsrooms. There’s a sense that you just get out there and it all falls into place. It’s not true though. You will always get better if you’re deliberate about the way you practice.
Newspaper writing is a craft. A real one. A difficult one. And not one that you will happen upon by accident. If you are interested in news writing, at the very least you should have consumed News Writing by Anne McKane, Letters To A Young Journalist by Sam Freedman, and the books that form the core part of the NCTJ qualification. Also: read newspapers every single day. And not just the papers that you like, or the stories that you like. Read several papers and all kinds of stories. Analyse first lines. Watch how facts are interwoven. Start practising now. How would you improve the intro? What crucial fact was missing?
#4 Learn to edit
I am not a good writer. I’m not even a good proofreader. But I have learned to hack away at my words and make them vaguely understandable. It is not easy and I wasn’t a natural. But I’ve gathered a few tricks to help. First, I write sentences so that I could understand them if it was in a second language that I vaguely understand. Second, I use Grammarly, which is ridiculously expensive but I’ve continued shelling out for years so it must be doing something right.
#5 Live a little
First off, I am suspicious of people who do journalism undergraduate degrees. Why? Because knowing the technical aspects of newspaper reporting doesn’t actually help when you are investigating crime squads, or financial documents, or the scientific policies of a regulator. It is much better if you know something. This does not mean you must avoid journalism degrees. When I was the editor at SchoolsWeek several of our best journalists had these degrees – but also had to do the hard work of getting specialised in the school sector and it often took a while. How much easier would it have been if they had worked in a school for a bit first? I’ve also worked with journalists who didn’t go to university at all, and instead spent time out on the beat from when they were about 10. (Don’t worry, this wasn’t a child labour law issue, they just did it themselves).
Outside of your studies, you can be a journalist everywhere. Challenge yourself to go on a walk and see how many stories you can find. Are there roadworks? What’s on the local noticeboard? Find a lampost or building with a planning permission note tied to it (they exist!) These are stories. Write about them. On a blog, in a notebook, make a Tik Tok. Use every opportunity to practice your craft.