Laura McInerney
4y ago
Co-Founder of Teacher Tapp, the influential daily survey app. Recovering education journalist: former editor of @SchoolsWeek and @Guardian columnist.
Over the years, I've come to the conclusion that people will only vote for a Prime Minister who they believe will act a certain way if aliens invaded. 👽
HOW the person would act during the invasion matters less than KNOWING how the person would act.
Let me explain...
If aliens invaded, how do we think Boris Johnson would act? He'd likely try to greet them with his usual humour, grabbing his hair, shaking their hands & telling everyone that he's doing all he can to ensure the aliens will deliver the people's priorities.
Even if the aliens were holding placards saying 'we come to eat you' and were roaming the streets chomping on children, Johnson would still hold a press conference to tell us everything is okay and he totally had it under control.
One of the problems Keir Starmer has is that it's not obvious what he would do in an alien invasion 👽. Ed Miliband had the same problem. To an extent, so did Corbyn. He'd probably have said that he was hopeful of peace but... then what?
This sounds glib, but it gets to the heart of what 'trust' often means in politics and why Johnson is popular in his party and was in the 2019 election. Trust isn't always about gained by doing 'the right thing' it's often about doing a consistent and authentic-seeming thing.
If the Labour Party want to win the next general election, they need to think about what their leader in that election - be it Starmer, or someone else - would do in an alien invasion.
And if Labour think it's a stupid question that's impossible to answer, then it's worth reminding them that, in 1997, had aliens invaded, it's quite clear what Blair would have done: a big smile, a broad handshake, and a positive uplifting speech.
Hence, a party leader's style doesn't have to be dramatic: it just needs to be consistent and give enough information to know how an alien crisis would be handled 👽. Starmer isn't there yet.
If he doesn't have it in him, who in the Labour Party do you think could?