Laura McInerney
4y ago
Co-Founder of Teacher Tapp, the influential daily survey app. Recovering education journalist: former editor of @SchoolsWeek and @Guardian columnist.
Should schools ban mobile phones?
You may have a hunch. But we recently surveyed over 4,000 secondary school teachers via @TeacherTapp to see if phones are genuinely disruptive & bans are the solution.
Here's what we found:
1 - Kids using phones in lessons is rife.
On the day we surveyed, 1 in 3 teachers said at least one pupil had taken their phone out during a lesson without permission. That's just on ONE day.
Several teachers wrote to tell us it happened to them every day, multiple times!
2 - The number of kids using mobile phones in lessons was also the same in May 2021. So at least things aren't getting worse. Yet!
But would a ban make any real difference?
There's reason to believe it would...
3 - A few months earlier, we'd asked teachers about their school's mobile phone policies. Choices were:
Allowed at break & in lesson when directed
Allowed at break but never in lesson
Not allowed at any time unless specified by a teacher
Not allowed at any time
4 - We looked to see if the teachers who told us pupils had phones out in their lessons worked in a school with any particular type of policy. And they did!
Teachers in schools with total bans were much less likely to see a child take out their phone. (The fourth group below)
5 - The schools where pupils were allowed to have phones at break and lunch, even if they were not allowed in lessons, had over 40% of teachers saying they'd seen a phone out in lesson ON THAT DAY.
6 - Of course, it's worth noting that even in the schools with total bans, some kids still got their phones out.
27% of teachers saw a phone out in the lesson that day even though phones are totally banned.
7 - From this it therefore seems that:
a more permissive policy on use at break and lunch does correlate with more inappropriate use in classrooms, BUT
total bans also may not be total!
If you've enjoyed this thread, and like education research, please download @TeacherTapp (via teachertapp.co.uk) and join our panel. It's free, easy, quick - and you get badges. What's not to like!
teachertapp.co.uk