Lily Bruns
/lilyszabo
Global citizen, writer, and community builder. My writing explores remote work and nomad visas as part of my mission to build a country on the internet.
Lily Bruns
4y ago
Community is essential to pushing forward an innovation as wide-sweeping in its potential as remote work.
While ideating in public is a great way to build connections, to make change happen we must collaborate and build coalitions.
The remote revolution requires an enlightened collective to become a force for good.
If you're interested in leveling up your remote work skills, launching a remote-first startup, or engaging in advocacy work - you'll want to check out these great online communities.
Running Remote
One of the few newsletters I actually read and look forward to, Running Remote has a proven track record for staying on the pulse of the remote revolution, and an emphasis on knowledge sharing.
While the newsletter is an easy way to tap into the network, there is also a major annual conference and vibrant Slack group for remote entrepreneurs and executives.
Digital Nomad Community by NomadX
While it looks like they're getting ready to launch on their own platform, the fastest way to dive into Gonçalo Hall's NomadX community is via his Facebook Group.
Chat with fellow nomads to get advice on how to start and maintain the lifestyle, destination and travel tips, and plan meetups around the world.
Executive Remote Workers
As it says on the tin, this group for Executive Remote Workers is led by Kristie Sullivan and focused on helping high-level professionals take advantage of work from anywhere.
They say you're the average of the five people you spend the most time with, so if you're looking to stay ahead in your career, this community can help keep you sharp and challenge you to push boundaries.
Draper Entrepreneur Network
Silicon Valley certainly doesn't have a monopoly on talent and good ideas, but it's extremely hard for founders to get funding outside of this exclusive network. Thankfully, some good folks are addressing this imbalance.
Draper Startup House's online community is dedicated to supporting founders - no matter where they are in the world.
While their investment fund and syndicate network are a great draw, the real value of the community comes from the chance to connect with fellow founders and mentors both online and offline at their many partner coworking spaces.
Plumia
What exactly does a country on the internet for digital nomads do? This Safetywing-backed moonshot project has a goal to create a passport for digital nomads, and that's just one of many global ambitions.
Through a series of online talks, community mixers, a publishing arm, and Discord channel, there are a multitude of ways to participate in the community. I love Plumia for being a wonderful place to explore exciting new ideas with fellow nerds and really push the envelope in imagining how the remote work revolution can make the world a better place.
What's your favorite place to connect online with remote workers for support and inspiration?
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
To the policymakers and advocates trying to launch visas and boost local tech ecosystems - don't make the mistake of imposing restrictions in an attempt to control the "quality" of digital nomads who apply.
Quantity has a quality all its own, and innovation is a numbers game.
if you're trying to attract entrepreneurs and investors, you need a certain amount of startup creation and deal flow to happen. Most of those new businesses will fail, a few rocketships will launch, but a tiny tiny tiny fraction will ever have a chance to become the prized unicorn.
If you want to create unicorns, you need volume.
And if you think digital nomads and remote workers can help supply the raw talent, ideas, and networks to boost innovation, then you need to attract lots and lots of them without being overly discriminating.
You don't control for quality at the top of the funnel by gatekeeping.
The criteria you can impose like setting a minimum salary or requiring a master's degree aren't actually predictors of success in startup creation.
The world's wealthiest digital nomad, Ethereum founder Vitaly Buterin, is a college dropout, as are many famous tech founders.
You create value by making resources available and incentivizing good behaviors.
Create the conditions for this outside talent to become integrated in your startup ecosystem. Focus on the grassroots community support and creating a good culture.
Some ideas and examples:
Create a free coworking space for remote workers and locals alike will enjoy. Run lots of events and support networking.
Create English-language content to highlight your ecosystem.
Identify the organization who are already doing good innovation work, and enlist them to recruit and manage talent.
Make renewing or extending the visa contingent upon positive activities like volunteering and mentorship (managed with the assistance of partners like universities, accelerators and coworking spaces).
Don't worry too much about people exploiting your new visa. I promise you, the bad guys who want to get into your country are going to find a way in.
Overly strict criteria create a negative selection bias.
You'll just deter the upstanding citizens who lie following rules and shoot yourself in the foot. Digital nomads and remote workers from the highly developed countries you're probably trying to draw them from like processes that are simple.
That's the same reason that if you don't have a nomad visa or make remote work by those visiting your country legal you will struggle to attract enough of this tech talent that has been unleashed by remote work.
Easy enough for me to say right? I understand that pushing policy forward means protecting many interests and risks must be managed, but that's what entrepreneurship demands - no risk no reward!
Remember, almost 80% of America's unicorns were founded by foreigners.
Estonia, which punches way above its weight in the creation of unicorn startups allows local employment on their nomad visa, and their salary minimum is equivalent to the base pay for a local software engineer.
You can't judge the potential value someone brings in the future based on their current salary.
VC's who literally make a living betting on founders don't use that as a metric - so why would you?
I love my home country of Thailand so so so much, but the SMART Visa which launched in 2018 has only had 200 or so successful applicants out of the 2000 that applied...
If you want to create visas to attract tech talent, don't repeat this mistake.
Lily Bruns
4y ago
Nothing against those OG engineers - they took teleworking to the next level and kickstarted the nomad movement, but these days, digital nomads are a rather diverse group.
Some assumptions and stereotypes about nomads are still true:
Many many nomads work in tech and marketing.
There are still a lot more dudes than ladies that nomad.
Thanks to passport privilege, most nomads are from the US, UK, Germany and other Western nations.
But the average does not define the group!
Here are some of my favorite nomadic leaders and new LinkedIn friends breaking the mold:
Rowena Hennigan - Nomadic Families
Helping others make the most of the remote lifestyle with her company RoRemote, Rowena also speaks frequently about how family plays a central role in her nomadic lifestyle.
She recently highlighted her family's experience in Sintra with Boundless Life: https://digitalnomadsdaily.com/podcast/a-digital-nomad-family-enjoying-it-part-time-with-rowena/
Maya Middlemiss - Nomad Freelancers
While an increasing share of digital nomads are remote employees, Maya Middlemiss proves that the freedom of freelancing is still a powerful force!
Check out the podcast she produces for Xolo: https://futureisfreelance.buzzsprout.com/
Mitko Karshovski - Third Culture Kids
Mitko is American, and he is also very not American having spent his early formative years in Bulgaria. As an immigrant, third culture kid, and digital nomad, Mitko's talent for meta-analysis and approaching ideas from multiple perspectives brings punch to his work.
That Remote Life is hands-down one of the best podcasts about remote work and digital nomads: https://thatremotelife.com/
Kristie Sullivan - Executive Nomads
Nomads are real adults ruling the C-Suite and Kristie Sullivan is reshaping expectations about who can be a nomad, and what that lifestyle looks like a range of professionals.
Check her out at https://executiveremoteworker.com/
Sarah Hawley - Nomadic Founders
This absolute legend had a baby, published a book, and launched a startup in the same year. Sarah Hawley is defying the expectation of what a tech founder looks like and how they lead, and remote work is baked into her life and mission.
Currently fundraising on Republic, it's clear that the crowd is behind her: https://republic.com/growmotely
Weh'yee Barkon - Nomads in Africa
On a mission to reverse brain drain and bring nomads to Africa, Weh'yee is helping reshape perceptions of the longest inhabited continent and encouraging nomads to adventure beyond the usual hotspots.
Connect with him on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wehyeeba/
Nomadic subcultures abound, and how nomads work is as varied as where they choose to go. If you thought all nomads were the same bromads, I encourage you to follow these humans and broaden your horizons.
Lily Bruns
4y ago
So you want to help create a nomad visa in X country? Here's one approach based on how I got involved in this advocacy work.
1. Get Inside the Community
In 2018 I cofounded the Chiang Mai Entrepreneurship Community with friends around the mutual goal of connecting digital nomads, expats, and local business owners to foster knowledge exchange and create opportunities.
As a leader in this community, I had a chance to hear from diverse people and note common concerns that came up - one of those was the challenges visas posed to movement, and more importantly integration.
As someone motivated to do good for my community, the crucial role visas play in encouraging or preventing economic and skills integration struck me as both a key leverage point and a glaring gap.
To an entrepreneurial mind, that reeks of opportunity!
If you want to become a nomad visa advocate, it's essential you get the pulse of the people you want to represent. You don't have to be a digital nomad to do this work, but it's essential to be part of the community whether that is in your locality or the digital sphere.
2. Find the Data
When I started to reach out to civil servants and the people who had their hand in policy, a recurring question came up:
How many digital nomads are there? Nobody had the answer...
Everybody I spoke to was interested, but nobody had enough info to really understand who nomads were, whether or not they were important, and how the community could be reached.
Tapping into the community we built through CMEA, we quickly put out a survey that generated hundreds of responses within a week. There was a ton of interest, and it turned out people had been waiting for an outlet and representation. We happily filled this role.
Late 2019, we put together a press conference (I had never done this before! Intimidating!) and presented the results of our findings.
This was well received by the media, and opened the doors to conversations with the power-brokers and people of influence who could move this agenda forward.
Data and statistics are your friend. Educate yourself and start collecting sources of information about your community. Organize this information and make it widely available.
3. Tell a Good Story
While data was crucial to answering fundamental questions, we realized the most important thing to do was reframe the narrative. There was a strong belief that nomads were broke, backpacking, ponzi-scheming bums. Yowch.
It was clear that a good amount of the work ahead would be to rebrand the community in local hearts and minds.
For every story we presented about a nomad who ran a skillshare workshop for local women entrepreneurs or new businesses co-founded with formerly nomadic techies, there were ten Go-Fund-Mes for uninsured nomads who couldn't afford a ticket home after getting busted up in a bike accident and 20 Youtube videos bragging about how nomads were living in Thailand as cheaply as possible...
You generate interest with data, but you change hearts and minds with stories. Build a cohesive positive narrative in your community and make it easy for others to do the same.
4. Connect with other Policy Makers & Advocates
My nomad visa efforts in Thailand were pretty much mothballed by the pandemic. Proposals died as budgets were gutted and power-battles at the top meant my inside peeps were suddenly nudged aside. While I still had updates from fellow advocates I had connected with, the news wasn't good.
I was devasted and almost ready to pack it in, but suddenly I heard from advocates in Indonesia and Sri Lanka. They had noted my efforts and wanted advice. It was a joy to help them!
It occurred to me my hardwon experience might benefit others so throughout the pandemic I connected with gov't reps and fellow advocates while running virtual events - I developed a reputation as the nomad visa girl and that's pretty much led me to where we are now.
Policy change is a long hard slog. Build coalitions to create momentum, and connect with others who share your mission to keep each other inspired and motivated.
Join the mission with me!
These days, I'm having tons of fun engaging with nerdy remoters in Plumia,
Safetywing's not-for-profit movement to create a country on the internet for digital nomads.
If you're inspired to help create a better world, learn more and join us at plumia.org!
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
If you've been following my writing these last two weeks, you've read a lot of my ideas and critiques on nomad visas. You can find the entire series to date here: https://medium.com/@lilyszabo
I've had the benefit of learning from advocates and officials alike as I've worked to enable better mobility solutions for nomads. If you're interested in doing the same, here are some excellent resources for getting up to speed on this topic:
1. Global Natives, Lauren Razavi
My adventuresome nerd pal and the Executive Director of Plumia wrote about the past, present, and future of the digital nomad movement. A respected thought leader in this space, she even spoke at the UN earlier this year!
2. Future of Remote Work and Human Migration, Pieter Levels
Founder of Nomad List, Pieter Levels is probably the OG digital nomad futurist. He famously predicted back in 2015 that there would be 1 billion digital nomads by 2035. While that oft-cited piece was compelling, his post-pandemic follow-up is an excellent brief on the many waves of digital nomadism and the bigger picture of remote work.
3. Ultimate Remote Worker Visa List, A Brother Abroad
A thorough exploration of digital nomad visas as well as a variety of other visa types that nomads use around the world, Carlos Grider's list is expansive and well-researched. He has also gifted us with this incredible stats list on digital nomads.
4. Work from Anywhere Team's Digital Nomad Visa Directory
John Lee is so charming and thoughtful, he makes the topic of international tax compliance genuinely interesting. His company has put together this thorough list for exploring your nomad visa options.
5. Global Nomad Guide Digital Nomad Visa Guide
Shorter but more densely researched, Global Nomad Guide is a government-vetted directory of digital nomad visas. Anna Jaworska reviews a number of remote worker programs and has a handy index for evaluating countries' performance.
6. Harvard Business Review on Digital Nomad Visas
Exploring the potential benefit digital nomads might bring to a country, this article has a very handy chart outlining the requirements of forty odd nomad visa schemes.
7. Should OECD Countries Develop New Digital Nomad Visas?
Published just this July, IMO this paper is a bit mixed up in its use of "digital nomads" vs "remote workers" but is an excellent exploration into existing programs and provides insights from a policy perspective.
8. Video: Karoli Hindriks on Estonia's Digital Nomad Visa
If you prefer video over reading, then this is one of my favorite Plumia Talks interviewing changemakers and policy experts playing a part in the digital and remote enabled future. Hindriks' day job is running Jobbatical, a global relocation company, and she advised the Estonian gov't on their creation of the DN visa. She also has a fabulous TED Talk on why the passport is due for an upgrade.
Happy reading 🤓
Tomorrow I'll loop back with the story of my nomad visa advocacy journey and some insight to how my home country of Thailand has approached this topic (expect high levels of sass and a scathing review of the new LTR program).
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
What with all the critiques, it might seem like I am a big downer on countries launching nomad visas. Far from it! I applaud the risk-taking and innovation 👏
I'm just not one to hand out participation trophies.
Constructive criticism from the community is what's needed to iterate and improve upon digital nomad visas.
To shift the tone in a more positive direction, I want to hand out a few gold stars to countries that are doing a commendable job with their approach to attracting nomads (even if that doesn't equal success in nomad visa uptake!).
🇪🇪 Estonia - the Digital Nomad Visa OG ✊
This Baltic destination is a digital innovator and tech powerhouse punching way above its weight with startup unicorns. While they were not the first to launch a nomad visa, Karoli Hindriks should get the credit for originating this concept back in 2018.
With their e-Residency program, they were one of the first to really see the potential of a borderless digital world and pay attention to location-independent entrepreneurs as a valuable target market.
🇧🇧 Barbados - Pushing the Frontier 🚀
First out the gate, the Barbados Welcome Stamp program to attract remote workers to this Caribbean island launched July 2020. This was early in the pandemic when nomads were scrambling to find places they were still welcomed.
Barbados attributes $100M+ of increased revenue on the success of this program!
While the country has always been easy to enter, clever PR and a genuine interest in pushing an innovation agenda (they're also the first country to launch an embassy in the metaverse) make them stand out.
🇵🇹 Portugal - No Nomad Visa No Problems 😎
Digital nomad community leader Gonçalo Hall has long been a vocal about the fact that countries need to focus on launching nomad communities ahead of nomad visas. With the runaway success of the Digital Nomad Village, Madiera, it's worth paying attention to his wisdom.
That said, Portugal does bank on a longstanding reputation as a nomad hotspot. Plus the D7 visa, while not tailor-made, does fit the bill as a nomad-friendly visa solution.
🇬🇪 Georgia - K.I.S.S. 😘
Notably permissive with its borders already, this small country sandwiched between Europe and Asia launched the Work Remotely from Georgia program in August 2020.
With a minimal amount of paperwork required, low fees, and speedy turnaround time, they have been praised for taking a simple approach to welcoming nomads through multiple visa channels.
🇨🇷 Costa Rica - Thank You for Listening 👂
You don't always get it right on the first try, and instead of responding to criticism with resistance, you can listen, and that's exactly what this eco-friendly expat haven did.
Costa Rica started teasing details of their application process last year and it was no bueno, but when the program was finalized in July, it was stripped down, simplified, and exactly what the community was asking for - with a notably reasonable income requirement to boot.
These five countries are worlds apart in their challenges, opportunities, and economic development needs. And yet, they're all gung ho for nomads and making a big point of rolling out the welcome mat.
What are your thoughts on the five above programs and approaches? Have you tried out any of these visas? I would love to hear your thoughts!
Tomorrow, I'll be summarizing my advice to countries about how they ought to court digital nomads effectively before I move on to sharing tips for other nomad visa advocates.
Lily Bruns
4y ago
My number one complaint about the current slate of digital nomad visas is that we have a communication issue. The term digital nomad has been coopted, and the in-group ain't happy about it.
What are being called "digital nomad visas" right now would be more correctly called "remote worker visas."
Within the larger category of remote workers, there is huuuuuge variation in type of employment, residency status, housing situation, and desire to travel.
Remember: all digital nomads are remote workers, but not all remote workers are digital nomads.
Digital nomads represent the subcategory of remote workers who are the most mobile and desirous of living outside their home countries.
While it may seem like I have been talking down nomad visas, there are things many of them get right, and the most common language defining eligibility around these visas does cover digital nomads.
We can see Estonia's example:
Who is eligible to apply?
You can apply for the digital nomad visa if you meet the following requirements
You are able to work independent of location
You can perform your work duties remotely using telecommunications technology
You either have an active employment contract with a company registered outside of Estonia, conduct business through your own company registered abroad, or work as a freelancer for clients mostly outside of Estonia.
This is a very good thing. And as per my notes on why countries would target nomads, it absolutely makes sense countries ultimately want remote workers to settle and immigrate.
But what nomads want to start out with is visas - not residency programs which is what most of these so-called nomads visas truly are. As I've said before, the problem to be solved now is simply visas that allow people to legally work while traveling.
Countries are misunderstanding needs, jumping the gun thus shooting themselves in the foot.
Let's switch this to a dating metaphor.
If you're into someone, do you start by demanding that they move in and sign a lease just in order to spend time with you?
Or do you date each other first, get to know one another, really see one another at your best and worst, fall in love, and then when it makes sense for them, offer to let them move in?
I'm glad that these new digital nomad visas exist, but their whole approach is a real turn-off to the community.
A better approach is to look at these visa and residency schemes as a funnel and introduce appropriate channels to match needs and expectations.
That said, there are some interesting experiments being done, and credit to the countries taking a risk and innovating in this direction!
Tomorrow, I'll explore some of the most notable experiments in attracting nomads as part of countrys' economic agendas.
Lily Bruns
4y ago
Depending on who you ask, there are now anywhere from 30 to 100 digital nomad visas. You would think this would be happy news and cause for celebration within the nomadic community.
Alas, this giddiness is only for the media. Amongst nomads, honestly, there's more griping than anything.
Why?
Because the majority of digital nomads don't use nomad visas.
In fact, they can't. Most so-called digital nomad visas miss the point of who nomads are and aren't and create criteria and offerings that don't actually serve the community.
I've written about what I think a good nomad visa should look like, and tomorrow I'll dive into my major critiques against the current nomad visas. But first, let's do a reality check on how nomads actually move across borders.
The majority of nomads take the path of least resistance and use tourist visas. Duh.
Despite the fact that many countries explicitly forbid work of any kind whilst visiting, this is just way easier. Oftentimes, the rules aren't very strictly enforced. So long as you keep your head down, it won't become an issue.
Tourist visas have their limits though - primarily due to the short length of stay, but also because opening a bank account, getting a lease and many other functional things can be restricted on tourist visas.
Remember that we nomads work - that's what sets us apart from the true holiday makers!
It's a hassle being constantly on the move and living in limbo. So those of us who have been at it a while prefer to move slowly, settle down for a few months at a time, and establish a base for exploration.
When tourist visas don't cut it or we want to put down temporary roots, we use whatever means is 1) best understood 2) most cost-effective and 3) recommended by others in our network. Whether these solutions make us fully legal alas seems irrelevant to most of the community.
Grey area > hassle.
In order of hassle + price, here are some of the way nomads make longer stays possible:
Border-Bouncing
Some countries, such as Malaysia, make it easy to come in, enjoy the entirety of your stay, leave the country - even just for the day - and re-enter on a fresh tourist visa. If you're British, apparently, you can do this and live in Hong Kong for a long time.
Passive-Income or Self-Employment Visas
Portugal's D7 Visa and Costa Rica's Rentista Visa are two examples of visa and residency schemes that simply require you to prove you have an income from outside the country. Some such visas are easy to obtain, others like Spain's Non Lucrative Visa, are notoriously a hassle.
Pay-to-Play Schemes and Golden Visas
Only for the wealthy, this is how I'd loosely group programs like Thailand's Elite Visa (requires you to pay more than $20k upfront) or programs that grant residency for investment like Greece has (get a visa for investing €250,000 in real estate).
Whether remote working is allowable under these three types of visas varies from an explicit no to a notable silence on the topic.
To recap, while I am all about pushing for nomad visas, the lack of them is not stopping nomads from doing their thing, and many in the community aren't worried about breaking the rules.
The fact that they're not made for purpose implies some hassle or risk.
If you're interested in learning more about the types of visas that nomads use around the world, A Brother Abroad has quite a good list.
Now that we've gone over solutions nomads are using in actuality, we have a benchmark with which to compare the digital nomad visas which have been created - check back here tomorrow!
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
Better visas are obviously a great thing for nomads, but what's in it for countries and host communities?
The typical profile of digital nomads represents an attractive visitor/immigrant target group.
As of 2021, there are an estimated 35 million+ digital nomads roaming the globe, the population equivalent of Canada. With an annual spending power of $787 billion, they’d also be considered one of the world’s 50 most prosperous nations after Portugal and Saudi Arabia. [Source]
A digital nomads’ average paycheck is $4500 and they spend 36% of that locally. A nomad there for directly contributes $1620 a month, or $19,440 annually, that’s ~$2M in direct revenue for every 1000 nomads. [Source]
Remote workers represent some of the most highly educated and best paid segments of the workforce. They typically come from prosperous and highly developed countries. [Source]
So what economic agendas could nomads be plugged into?
Revitalizing Tourist Destinations
Tourism industries getting battered by the pandemic is what opened the door for countries to finally start welcoming digital nomads.
Nomads stay longer in host destinations, tend to party less, and leave a lighter carbon footprint. Nomads can provide a boost to local consumption and governments can collect that sweet juicy sales tax (or VAT).
Injecting Talent into Innovation Ecosystems
Highly skilled immigrants are always desirable. Highly skilled immigrants that don't take away local jobs, can help upskill the local population, and have a penchant for starting new businesses? Winning.
Whether through knowledge transfer or entrepreneurship, many host communities look to digital nomads for help with their startup and tech ecosystems.
Reversing Brain Drain & Depopulation
Good conditions for nomads can also mean good conditions for citizens. I'm a prime example - I could have stayed in New York or London for work, but I'd rather live in my hometown of Chiang Mai. Without remote work, this would never have been a viable option.
Whether it's by directly attracting immigrants or by improving economic conditions, remote work and digital nomads can help countries hang on to their best and brightest and guard against depopulation.
It's taken the pandemic to suddenly spur the creation of more than 30 digital nomad visas worldwide, but this is just the start.
What was once a counter-culture fringe movement is just the leading edge of a new world order ushered in by remote work.
Not since the industrial revolution spurred urbanism to new heights have we seen such a drastic reorganization of where and how people live.
Suddenly, work is no longer a place, and cities don't hold a monopoly on economic opportunity. Anyone with a computer and a wifi connection can make a living anywhere. A good living.
For a long time, mass migration has largely been driven by negative push factors such as war and lack of economic opportunity. Highly developed countries that offer work and stability have been the ones to pull people in. Thanks to remote work, the game is now anyone's to win.
The fundamental premise of protectionist border policies is eroding, and there is an opportunity to play a more benevolent game.
There's no guarantee that good intentions will win out, however, and plenty of reasons for things to go tits up in an icky neocolonial direction. Nomads, host communities, and policy-makers should be working together to make the best of this transition and find win-wins.
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
This past week, I've been exploring and critiquing digital nomad visas from the perspective of the user - of a digital nomad.
Whether it's product or policy design, getting into the user's mindset to understand their pain points and clearly outline the problem to be solved is essential.
And it's always easiest to write what you know. A 30 Day Writing Challenge is no joke to embark upon!
As I highlighted in my last post about nomads as a force for good, however, it's important to note the other key stakeholders, the host countries.
What's their interest in digital nomads and what skin are they putting in the game?
This week I'll be shifting perspective and exploring:
Why Countries Should Court Digital Nomads
Critiques on So-Called "Digital Nomad Visas"
An Overview of the Current Visa Landscape for Nomads
Case Studies of Notable Visas and Digital Nomad Policies
But first a refresher and context.
It's worth emphasizing again that I'm not interested in nomad visas just because remote work and designing a lifestyle around travel and geo-arbitrage is an amazing lifehack.
I believe the digital nomad movement is a unique point of leverage for tipping the new world order heralded by remote work into a force for good.
Pieter Levels famously predicted in 2015 that there would be 1 billion digital nomads by the year 2035. In his follow up on the next wave of human migration, he's laid out an extremely compelling case for the full impact of this change.
Dr. Parag Khanna explores the intersection of innovation and immigration, and he believes the digital nomad movement is fundamentally a political one.
I agree. Voting with your feet sends a powerful signal to countries and as a subset of "talented youth," just from a demographics standpoint, nomads are exceptional. As an activist movement, the potential is absolutely thrilling.
It's why I'm so excited to be a part of Plumia, the initiative to create a country on the internet for digital nomads. When Lauren Razavi talks about creating win-wins in the global border system, I go full fangirl.
It's why I've sat down in front of my laptop every evening even though I'm absolutely exhausted from taking care of my 6-month old all day. Because this shit matters and I believe in advocacy and creating a better future.
But it doesn't hurt that playing with these ideas is like intellectual candy to me, and it's such a delight to engage with others who are also curious and passionate about these topics!
Thanks for following along so far, and I hope to continue to engage with y'all as I continue my many-many part dive into nomad visas.
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
In my last post, I finally laid out what a good digital nomad visa should look like. Many of you commented that a tourist visa would be much simpler...
And I actually do agree.
Every country should acknowledge reality and make it explicitly okay to work remotely while visiting on a tourist visa.
Then problem solved right? No need for nomad visas. Nomads travel with tourist visas easy peasy!
But I'm not an advocate for making travel more convenient for already privileged nomads - I think nomad visas can be a stepping stone to transforming global mobility and creating a more just world.
Making it acceptable to work on tourist visas takes digital nomadism out of the grey area, in essence decriminalizing it. Similar to the cannabis industry, however, to truly capture the benefits you need to legalize it.
There are two broad reasons I personally believe in this:
Countries Can Use Digital Nomads to Solve for X
Nomads can play a part in a variety of economic development agendas. I'll be exploring this in more detail later in the week, but suffice to say, I do not believe in magical thinking and "if you build it they will come."
Yes, more nomads as tourists might somehow help your startup problem or revitalize so and so region, but do you want to leave it all to chance? Why not send a clear signal? Why not create channels to encourage outcomes?
Tourism is a very broad net. If you're looking to catch a certain type of fish, it's nice to have a way of helping them swim to you. That's just marketing.
Nomad Visas Can Level Passport Privilege
Many of the nomad visa schemes out now are only offered to citizens from countries that could already visit visa-free! Talk about solving a non-existent problem...
I have a US passport, which means I get to enter 150+ countries visa-free or visa on arrival. My problem as a nomad is the aforementioned grey area issue. Stressful perhaps, but it doesn't stop me from doing my thing.
An Indian or a Phillipino nomad? They're shit out of luck. And these are two of the top countries for tech and business process outsourcing - these peeps are all ready to work remote! But it's nigh impossible for them to nomad internationally, and I think that's bogus.
Nomad visas will allow countries to attract visitors and potential immigrants based on a clear profile: this is someone with skills and knowledge. Letting a person in or not just based on where they were born? How arbitrary is that?! Talent is talent.
What do you think? Are these two reasons worth pushing for an alternative or do you think tourist visas are the way to go?
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
What would a good #digitalnomadvisa look like?
APPLICATIONS CAN BE MADE ONLINE
100% online, from anywhere in the world, no need to travel to an embassy.
MINIMAL PAPERWORK/DOCUMENTS
Passport, proof of income, and health insurance.
MULTIPLE ENTRIES & NO MINIMUM RESIDENCY
Nomads don't want to be trapped within the country for the duration of the visa. Flexibility and being able to make plans on the fly is key.
LENGTH OF 6 MONTHS
More is fine, but less gets in the way of long-term planning. Nomads have to get work done, so maintaining some stability/predictability is important.
NO COMPLICATED INCOME TAX
Either nix the income tax entirely, or make it super straightforward and simple to pay. Nomads don't mind paying local taxes, they mind hassle and confusion.
EMPLOYEES, FREELANCERS & ENTREPRENEURS ALL ELIGIBLE
If you must provide proof of employment to qualify, then your visa is not for digital nomads, it's probably for remote workers.
Help me out here fam, am I missing anything?
Keeping it simple works best for both nomads and host countries.
What nomads want is to enter a country basically like a tourist, but with the reassurance that they are not breaking any rules by working. Some clarity around taxes would be helpful. The ability to access local services like banking and telecom, and to use a valid foreign driver's license would also be dope.
Based on what's available now, Costa Rica gets a gold star 🇨🇷
The problem to be solved isn't the ability to move across borders, or even to establish temporary residency. Channels exist.
The problem is having the appropriate channel so nomads can openly declare themselves and no longer exist in a grey area.
There are in fact two approaches, decriminalization vs. legalization, and both would work, but I think one is better for the big picture.
More on this tomorrow.
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
In order to fix digital nomad visas, we need to get on the same page about who or what digital nomads are.
Not everybody who combines work and travel should be considered a digital nomad, we can lean on the digital part of the phrase to create a rule:
Digital nomads work using internet-enabled digital technologies.
Migrant laborers, cruise ship entertainers, and academic field researchers may all travel as a necessary part of their work, but we can conveniently exclude such people.
The second prerequisite is the nomad part:
Digital nomads move around frequently.
This is a little less definitively tidy (and this subjectivity is at the heart of the nomad visa issue).
But since we're talking visas, let's use other categories of travelers and say a nomad is between a tourist and an expat on the spectrum of time spent abroad - how do we determine then what "frequently" means?
Data can help with that.
My 2019 research suggested nomads visit 5-8 countries a year, and my 2020 survey says a quarter of nomads spend 1-3 months at a destination, while a third spend 3-6 months.
According to Pieter Level's Nomad List, nomads spend on average 8 months in one place, so we're not all in perfect agreeance...
But based on many conversations, these limited references, and a heaping spoonful of regard for my own opinion:
The sweet spot for nomads is 3-6 months.
Longer than that and not only do the tax implications start becoming a thing, but you start acting pretty settled and accumulating stuff.
A visa for digital nomads should be geared towards people who fit this definition.
Why?
Because tourists, expats, and immigrants already have visa and residency options!
If the short and long-term channels already exist, you're not really innovating or solving a problem - you're opportunistically rebranding your existing solution.
(Which fair enough, I can understand wanting to get on the hype train.)
Now that we've established who digital nomads are, tomorrow I'll come back and explain what it is they actually want out of a visa.
P.S. For a more expansive and historically contextualized answer to who digital nomads are, Lauren Razavi's book, Global Natives is the definitive work.
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
The real problem with digital nomad visas?
It's fundamentally a problem with the phrase digital nomad itself. Nobody is agreed on what this means.
Issue 1: Digital nomads can't agree on what this means
When somebody first called me a digital nomad back in 2016, I objected to the label.
I was based in London and had popped back to my hometown of Chiang Mai for a visit. When my favorite bartender asked me what I was doing back in town, I told him I was working remotely.
"You're one of those digital nomads now!"
I was flabbergasted. Can one even be a digital nomad whilst in their hometown?! While I embrace the term now, I'm not the only one who's part of this in-group yet rejects the term.
As a marketer working with remote companies and hospitality startups, I've seen brands shy away from this term more often than not - opting for remote workers, digital professionals, location-independent entrepreneurs and any handful of phrases that allude to digital nomad sans the semantic baggage it's accumulated.
For some, digital nomads are failed travel bloggers, hucksters scamming people with their course on how to become a digital nomad, shoe-string tourists toting MacBooks, or other delinquents engaging in a zero-dollar circle-jerk digital economy.
When I've faced obstacles in my visa advocacy - it's usually to do with this bad rap.
For others, the meaning of digital nomad is far broader and encompasses everyone from billionaire tech-founders to families traveling fulltime, but perceptions can be slow to change, and we don't have centralized representation (yet).
Issue 2: Media can't resist using this phrase for hype
Despite the Marmite quality of the term digital nomad to those within the group, journalists, bloggers, and PR professionals the world over absolutely adore the phrase.
Anything that vaguely falls into the ballpark of digital nomad territory, they'll slap the label on.
Why? Because this is a community largely made up of people who make shit go viral for a living, and because we take the road less traveled, we have a culture of sharing information.
Marketing professionals are all drooling over the chance to get that sexy word-of-mouth coverage. That's why every country wanting to attract remote workers, location-independent entrepreneurs and freelancers, and jetsetting executives alike is slapping the digital nomad visa label on their new program - or even when they don't, some hacky blogger will happily do so for them.
This results in a communications clusterfuck where countries fundamentally do not understand the assignment, and the smart nomads get a little frustrated (it's icky to be used like that).
So we have all of these new temporary residency schemes and golden visas, but to date, still no solution that actually addresses the key pain points of the community.
It's a little bit maddening.
So who or what are digital nomads then? What pain points would a real nomad visa address? Stay tuned - I'll cover that tomorrow and the next day in this series!
Lily Bruns
Digital Nomad Visa
4y ago
I don't like to call myself an expert on nomad visas... but then I review the articles and policies coming out and realize - if I'm not then nobody is.
Because the people creating these policies certainly have no idea what they're doing! When you're truly innovating, expertise is only relative.
As someone who's been speaking to advocates and policy-makers alike on this topic for a few years, I have some ideas and opinions.
Here's how I first got interested in nomad visas:
It all started in 2019 with a love story.
There was a guy I met on Tinder, a digital nomad who had wandered into my hometown of Chiang Mai. He was thinking about picking up and moving to Vietnam because he heard they didn't hassle people about their visas so much there.
I was very not okay with this, and while there were a few other factors lining up, that's essentially the reason I became the postergirl for Thailand's nomad visa.
And here's why I'm committed to this work:
Alas, Thailand has still not made good on a nomad visa, but that Tinder guy did stick around - he and I are now married and the proud parents of a little girl born in the USA, living in Thailand, with grandparents hailing from Vancouver, Budapest, Phayao, and Charlottesville.
What kind of world will she grow up in? I hope it's one where she doesn't have to slog through 3x the bureaucracy to maintain her nationalities...
I believe national borders make as much sense as the question "where are you from?" Together with some smart folks, I'm advocating to improve global mobility and I think nomad visas will provide excellent leverage on this mission.