In order to fix digital nomad visas, we need to get on the same page about who or what digital nomads are.
Not everybody who combines work and travel should be considered a digital nomad, we can lean on the digital part of the phrase to create a rule:
Digital nomads work using internet-enabled digital technologies.
Migrant laborers, cruise ship entertainers, and academic field researchers may all travel as a necessary part of their work, but we can conveniently exclude such people.
The second prerequisite is the nomad part:
Digital nomads move around frequently.
This is a little less definitively tidy (and this subjectivity is at the heart of the nomad visa issue).
But since we're talking visas, let's use other categories of travelers and say a nomad is between a tourist and an expat on the spectrum of time spent abroad - how do we determine then what "frequently" means?
Data can help with that.
My 2019 research suggested nomads visit 5-8 countries a year, and my 2020 survey says a quarter of nomads spend 1-3 months at a destination, while a third spend 3-6 months.
According to Pieter Level's Nomad List, nomads spend on average 8 months in one place, so we're not all in perfect agreeance...
But based on many conversations, these limited references, and a heaping spoonful of regard for my own opinion:
The sweet spot for nomads is 3-6 months.
Longer than that and not only do the tax implications start becoming a thing, but you start acting pretty settled and accumulating stuff.
A visa for digital nomads should be geared towards people who fit this definition.
Why?
Because tourists, expats, and immigrants already have visa and residency options!
If the short and long-term channels already exist, you're not really innovating or solving a problem - you're opportunistically rebranding your existing solution.
(Which fair enough, I can understand wanting to get on the hype train.)
Now that we've established who digital nomads are, tomorrow I'll come back and explain what it is they actually want out of a visa.
P.S. For a more expansive and historically contextualized answer to who digital nomads are, Lauren Razavi's book, Global Natives is the definitive work.