User Avatar

Lulie

Knowledge Series

4y ago

Epistemology applied to everything.

Knowledge Series – Part 1: Falsity

Does something that's knowledge have to be true?

That's common sense! If I thought the sky is blue and it were actually green, that wouldn't be knowledge, it'd be a mistake.

But before the discovery of light wavelengths, we had a different understanding of what colour even was. We thought colour was inherent in the object, rather than a mix of properties of the object and an accident of biology that gives us 3 colour receptors instead of 2 or 5.

If you didn't realise this about how colour works, tetrachromats and dichromats would be magic.

It wouldn't be true for someone with tritanopia (blue/yellow colour-blindness) that the sky is blue.

The physical wavelengths would be the same, but wavelengths aren't what produce colour:

Metamerism is the phenomenon that mixes of two wavelengths (like blue and yellow) can look the same as a different wavelength (like green).

Magenta doesn't even exist as a wavelength! It purely arises from an accident of our visual system.

So if we all had tritanopia, language for describing the sky would have evolved differently.

Does that mean it's false that the sky is blue?

Well, if your concept of 'blue' doesn't include wavelengths and different-for-tritanopics – yes, it's false.

But even if it's false, it's still useful information. It contains truth, such as approximating most people's experience.

Turns out all knowledge is like this. None of our knowledge is perfectly airtight. There are always mysteries, problems, contradictions if you look closely enough. The alternative would require omniscience, infallibilism.

If we never have perfect truth, what is knowledge?

Stay tuned for Part 2.