Lulie
/lulie

Epistemology applied to everything.
Lulie
Knowledge Series
4y ago
The reason most people think authority is bad is it's unjust. It's coercive, it's illegitimate, it's arrogant, it's invalid – they don't have the right.
But there is a deeper reason authority is bad.
In Part 5, I discussed how knowledge actually grows: it's not something you get from a teacher, but rather something you recreate inside yourself, in response to problems you have.
People say argument from authority is bad because it's an invalid argument. Which is true, but why does that matter? Is it so we can safely ignore all arguments that come from authority—because they are unjustified?
That would be justificationism, which is just another kind of authority.
Using an invalid argument is bad because it means the argument doesn't solve the problem you want to solve.
If "Why X?" is answered by "Because I said so.", that doesn't actually answer the question. It's a non-sequitur (Latin for 'does not follow'). Argument from authority is a flaw in the argument – it's sweeping over a part of the explanation.
Explanation that you need in order to solve your problem!
The reason that all authority is bad is not because it is unjust (although it indeed isn't).
Rather, because it's judging ideas not based on whether they solve problems—not by merit—but by who said them.
This sabotages the growth of knowledge.
Authority hampers the ability to improve on ideas. Instead of the best idea winning, whoever has power wins. Might makes right.
Philosopher William Godwin (father of Mary Shelley, author of Frankenstein) in 1797 (!) had this to say:
"Let us consider the effect that coercion produces upon the mind of him against whom it is employed. It cannot begin with convincing; it is no argument. [...] If he who employs coercion against me could mould me to his purposes by argument, no doubt he would. He pretends to punish me because his argument is strong; but he really punishes me because his argument is weak."
Lulie
Knowledge Series
4y ago
Philosophers sometimes try to get around the infinite regress problem of justificationism (see Part 3) by appealing to an ultimate justification, or foundation.
The point of foundationalism — and simultaneously its downfall — is that it claims there is a foundation which cannot be criticised or improved.
In other words, a dogmatic base.
Why that base and not another? Just 'cuz.
Empirical observation, the Bible, an ultimate goal, an objective function, the laws of logic, biology – these all have been used as a foundation where it's impossible to reason any further.
Under foundationalism, if you disagree on a base, either it's impossible for you to ever agree (because you're coming from different frameworks), or the other person is wrong about which base is dogmatically correct (and they should let Jesus into their life on faith, or else they'll burn for eternity).
This is irrationalism. It says there's something that cannot be reasoned about or with. It's a claim that no progress is possible when it comes to the base – you're stuck with it.
Foundationalism also typically comes with a kind of infallibilism – we can relax because we have certainty that we found the right base, and so long as we build on this base then we can have certain knowledge.
This often leads to a rigid, black-white way of thinking: if we change the base, that undermines all knowledge that's built atop it.
(This sometimes—quite unnecessarily—causes existential crises for people who switch frameworks and have foundationalist intuitions!)
The actual shape of knowledge is more like an interconnected web of guesses.
Each node/guess can be changed – which can affect nodes around it but doesn't tumble the entire structure.
Wrong ideas can be useful and contain truth. It's not the case that they need to be airtight (or justified) to be valuable.
We don't need a foundation. The problem it's trying to solve – how to get justified knowledge – is a bad problem.
This means it's possible to make progress anywhere, in any direction, without having to refer back to an edifice.
“Every point is a boundary point.” — John Wheeler