Justificationism is the idea that the aim of science is to find justified ideas – to seek proof, authority, verification, support, probability, credence.
It sounds intuitive. Who wants unjustified ideas? Aren't unjustified ideas mere subjective opinion at best? Or mysticism? Or meaningless?
But it has a problem:
Trying to have justification for ideas leads to an infinite regress.
Say you believe something, and you think your reasons for believing it justifies this belief.
Well, what justifies those reasons? Presumably other reasons. And what justifies those reasons?...
So, it's never really justified, because each justification relies on another one, and so on.
Many philosophers have made attempts to get around this:
⛪️ Religious philosophers, for example, think the Bible is inherently justified, and you're just supposed to have faith.
🌅 Inductivists say the way to get justification is to make observations that confirm your theory, and the more confirming observations you make, the more justified it is.
🔍 Logical positivists went a step further and said the only meaningful ideas are those that can be verified by observation – i.e. it's not justified unless you can observe it. (Too bad logical positivism can't itself be observed...)
The thing all these philosophers have in common is that they think whatever they use to get around the infinite regress is a source of justification.
They try to solve the problem by using justification.
But there is a solution to this problem, and it does not involve justification at all.
Justificationists ask, "How do we know our theory is true?"
Karl Popper replies, "That's a bad question."
It already implies the infinite regress: it implies the answer must be justificationist. It's really asking, "How can we be justified in thinking that our theory is true?"
What we should be asking is: "How can we find better theories?"
Instead of trying to justify our ideas as right, we should try to find and solve problems with them. Solving problems then makes the theory better: each solution is concrete improvement.