In the previous atomic essay, I argued that all our ideas contain falsehoods, using the intuition-pump that even basic statements like "the sky is blue" aren't quite correct.
Before I answer what knowledge is, if not truth, I want to address an objection:
What about more precise theories, like in physics?
Copernicus' theory that planets orbit the sun was more correct than the previous geocentric theory that everything revolves around the world.
But it was still mistaken: it had planets orbit the sun in a circle. Kepler discovered planets move in an elliptical orbit. But we didn't know why they did (or, in detail, how) until Newton.
So, that settles it. Newton's laws are knowledge, and Copernicus' theory was mistaken.
Except Newton got Mercury's orbit wrong.
Einstein came along and corrected Newton's laws.
But that still wasn't the end of it: Today, Einstein's theory of general relativity conflicts with quantum theory.
So the smartest people in the history of the world have all been wrong.
If truth is the criterion for knowledge, nothing we have ever thought qualifies.
And a state of final truth isn't even desirable.
If we had the final truth, that would mean it's impossible to improve in that area. It would be the end of progress. Nothing left to solve, life would be boring.
Part 2 will cover how we came to this view, why Aristotle ruined philosophy, and what is knowledge.
For all that Galileo knew,
Not one of his statements are true.
He fought against the Church and lost
A battle bitter, despite his feat:
Ideas truthlike—but not complete
In a God's-eye view.