Shane Melanson
3y ago
Sharing thoughts on real estate investing, construction, development and raising money
The story of Jim and Chris… and why many new real estate developers lose money
Names have been changed for obvious reasons.
This post is based on recent conversations with two developers. Jim, his first project and Chris is a seasoned developer.
The goal of this post is to highlight how Chris thinks about risk and development and why he’s been successful.
First meetings:
Jim: I have this land at 123 Main Street, it’s 18,000 sq.ft and I’d like to build a Multifamily project on it. I’d like to know how much you think it will cost to build (psf)?
How long will it take.
How much do you charge to do this?
Reasonable questions- but out of sequence so the answers he gets will be unsatisfactory.
Compare this with my meeting Chris for the first time.
Shane, I have a lot at 500 Maple Street. We're building a 32 unit, wood frame building with 1 level of underground. Have you built this type of project before? What trades will you be using? What can I expect from you during preconstruction? Who on your team will be here and do you have the capacity to handle this project?
"Based on what I told you and assuming nothing crazy subsurface, what do you expect the cost to be (psf)?"
Here’s the big difference- Chris already KNOWS the cost, he’s not asking for information just to confirm I know what I'm talking about.
Seasoned developers come to meetings knowing most of the numbers (construction isn't magic). They are meeting to evaluate the people. If I hire you - are you going to help me solve the 100 problems that will come up.
Jim is fixated on finding the cheapest contractor, architect and consultants. Because Jim has not other context to base his decision on - just price.
Chris is looking for the best team and will negotiate price/terms after but understands he will pay for quality & certainty.
Here is one other big difference.
Jim is trying to do all his up front work for free, hoping he can get to a DP without risking money.
I understand that, it's why I tried too when I was new.
No one likes to spend money without certainty. But in the world of development, it is a process to eliminate risk and some projects just don't pencil out.
Chris has a proforma and budget ready with heavy contingencies for the unknowns. Then methodically engages consultants to zero in on the risk in the project.
Chris is not afraid to pull the pin on the deal and kill it if he finds something that is unacceptable.
Jim on the other hand, has closed on the land and so he has very few options.
There is no turning back, so he is committed to doing the project, regardless of what he finds. In fact, he is not asking questions like ‘what could kill me in this deal’?
He’s asking- who can tell me what I want to hear so I can get started ASAP.
Spend enough time in the development game and you’ll hear the horror stories from developers who have the battle scars…
a consultant didn’t calculate the amount of electricity for your building. You have tenants, but they can’t move in because you need a new transformer, which will take 6-9 months. (Lost Revenue of $500k + poor reputation)
Or, you thought you had right aways to bring in sewer, water, hydro to your building - only to find out that you need to get the neighboring property to grant you a new access. Delaying you a year and costing an extra $150k.
In development, no 2 projects are the same.
But, with experience you come to see the biggest risks (typically subsurface) and understand there are check points along the way.
Engaging people to help you evaluate the development on day 1 (not day 186) will cost you money - but if your team is good, they should be able to save you 2x what they charge.
Chris appreciates the foresight and views this part of the development. We are hired to help him.
Fred, price shops and finds someone who will tell him what he wants to hear. 9 months later, I drive by his site and construction has stopped.
Why? No idea... we weren't involved.
My first real estate mentor says this about development… Shane, there are no $1,000 (or even $10k) mistakes in development.
Don’t be shortsighted. Invest the time and money up front to truly understand your project.