Shane Melanson

Shane Melanson

/shanemelanson20

Shane Melanson

Sharing thoughts on real estate investing, construction, development and raising money

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

The only way some people will take action is when they have skin in the game.

image
The only way some people will take action is when they have skin in the game.
Shane Melanson

Value for Value - probably a controversial topic today.

 

Something I’ve struggled with for years:  is giving away my time/insights and information for free, actually helping people?  

 

Or, should I be charging for my time/information? 

 

In transparency, my bias has been towards free - with about a 90/10 split. 

 

I felt guilty for charging- thinking that it would be great to be able to help more people.  And, that people would appreciate the value and take action - grateful someone was so generous.

 

So, I wrote a book and gave it away free.

 

My podcast - 195 episodes over 3.5 years free

Hundreds of videos on youtube free.

Thousands of hours of phone calls - no charge.

 

And, I wanted to test one last ‘free’ give away.

 

I was considering giving away a training program I’d taken 3 years to create to investors, at no charge.

 

I was concerned about a few things- the biggest being, that the value would not be respected.

 

So, at a recent meeting with a successful entrepreneur who wanted to meet and discuss investing in CRE, I suggested I would give him this training - free.  He was looking to invest in another training and I thought, hey, don’t worry.  I’ll give you mine.

 

All I asked for was feedback and to go through it.  

 

That was almost 2 weeks ago and looking at my members area- still no log in.

 

People get busy.  They have things going on, family, life, work, health… it happens to everyone.

 

But, there was no consequence for not watching the videos.  There was no investment and so, while it probably seemed like a good idea at the time, life got in the way and now, it’s “I’ll get to it later”.

 

I’ve been guilty of this too.  

 

My dad gave me his set of P90X CD’s about 10 years ago.  They sat in my basement for 9 months until one day he asked for them back.

 

I said no problem - could I use them for 1 more week.

 

Next 7 days, I worked out everyday and got hooked.  I went out and bought my own set of P90X.

 

What changed?

 

Nothing really. 

 

The content on the Cd’s was the same.  Expect, until there was a deadline and I invested money into it, did I actually pay attention and take action.

 

When I look back at the people who paid for coaching, a book or advice - they take it seriously and then take action.

 

Just to show that I eat my own cooking, I am a believer in value for value.  

 

I am a partner in a construction company.

 

I could ask my business partner Mark to ‘help me out’ and do some ‘pro bono’ preconstruction work on our retail deal.  

 

But I don’t.

 

I pay him and here’s why.

 

Because when i have an important meeting and need Mark on the call - I don’t feel guilty asking him to be there.

 

I’m paying him for his time and expertise.  And, guess what.  When he makes a suggestion - because we’re paying, we listen.

 

If he was just showing up to random calls and making suggestions (that could be valuable) - if I was not paying him, I’d take what I liked and discard the rest.

 

If something is important enough - they will invest the required time, energy & money.  

 

If something is abundant and free- it’s easy to take for granted.  

 

Given these recent realizations, and knowing what my goal is (to actually help someone get a result) - free is a poor mechanism to do that.

 

Free is great to build trust.  

 

Because until someone consumes some level of content they have no idea if you are a person of substance.  

 

But, once that fundamental level of trust is formed, then advancing to a more defined arrangement makes sense.  

 

A proper business arrangement - in exchange for X I expect Y.  

 

If you agree or disagree - happy to hear your perspective.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Emotions & Rationale work Inversely

image
Emotions & Rationale work Inversely
Shane Melanson

I have gone through a bit of a transformation in the last 12 months that I thought would be worthwhile sharing.

While setting up my coaching business, I invested over $150k into courses, coaches, seminars and events.

I was committed to the idea of becoming a coach. I wanted to help professionals and business owners who wanted to invest in commercial real estate, do so safely. And, get paid for this help.

My coaching business never really took off.


I felt the value proposition was strong.

People would ask - how much money do I need? How long will it take? Can you guarantee I'll get a property in X time.

To which I told them the truth.

It would be hard. You're competing with people who do this full time. You'll need a min of $250k and more likely $1M. I don't know how long it will take to find a property - I did 2 deals last year.

I was attracting who were already doing well. They earned high 6 & 7 figures. They looked at the coaching pragmatically and decided it was not worth the effort for an uncertain outcome.

(In hindsight, I don't blame them).

The payoff, would be in the future.

It was somewhat uncertain - I could not guarantee they would find a suitable property in X time.

The learning curve was steep.

The required effort was high.

Comparing my coaching offering (long, hard, uncertain) to the coaches I was hiring (easy, fast, guaranteed), it's no wonder I kept buying into the dream.

One day it clicked for me.

I had just started working with my buddy (Mark) helping him in Construction company. We were in a meeting and a consultant had booked in a time to chat about how he was going to create marketing and sales processes to help us grow.

In less than 3 minutes, Mark cut the guy off and told him we'd follow up with him. Mark had zero emotions when it came to growing his business.

It was clear- can you help us, yes or no. If you spend 3 minutes on platitudes or fluffy talk, you're wasting my time.

That conversation woke me up.

Why was I buying into what these coaches were selling so quickly? Why was I so hopeful that something would work?

Instead of confronting the real reason few people were investing.

I was not selling hope. I was not selling a cookie cutter approach. And, people were not going to pay for something that was uncertain and difficult.

Reviewing my financials with my accounts, I could no longer ignore facts:

Coaching was costing me money

Developing real estate and growing the construction company was paying me.

In Jan 2023- I stopped coaching.

I would focus my energy in where I could influence the outcome direclty. I could find proeprties, raise money and attract developers who wanted to build with us.

It was simple and rational.

People would pay for the outcome. And, they would pay well.

It's similar to the options someone has to change their appearance.

Option A - hire a personal trainer, eat healthy food, drink lots of water and workout 3-5x week. Buget - few hundred dollars a month (max).

Option B - go to a cosmetic surgeon. Immediate results and no problem paying 10K+.

What's the point of sharing my realization?

As a reminder to me, the value in delivering the result people want. Successful people generally look for people who can deliver the results and they are not easily swayed by emotions.

I was on a call with a friend yesterday discussing a property he wanted to invest in. When I looked at it, I told him I thought it was a horrible idea.

Why do you want to buy it?

Because I want to get a property before May 30th this year?

Why?

I had a goal of getting 2 properties this year.

A random goal, fueled by emotions was pushing him down the path of investing in a property that could cause him hell for the next 10 years.

Stepping back and looking at the property rationally was simple.


What is the NOI? $125k.

What is the cap rate (what return would you want if you paid all cash). 8-10% minimum.

Based on that, the property should be $1.25M - $1.56M. Why are you offering 2.5M?

Ignore what the seller paid. Ignore what the broker told you.

Look at the simple facts.

There is little upside. The highest and best use of this property is to fix it up (at a cost of $500k) and increase the rents a few hundred dollars a month.

If you do everything right - it will be worth $2.5M in 2 years.

So, if you offer 2.5M, and put $500k into it - you'll basically work for 2 years to solve someone else's problem and lose half a million dollars.

This was a 10 minute conversation, that I suspect helped my friend save $2.5M and more importantly years of struggle.

Do you need a coach to do this?

No.

Just like sitting in that meeting with Mark.

You just need someone who has clarity on the problem you're trying to solve and isn't afraid to ask you the right (tough) questions.

The right questions will take you out of the emotional high of 'buying'. And, focus on the rational questions- why are you buying? Is it right for you? What could go wrong?

There are no shortcuts to growing a business or investing in CRE. There will always be a buyer of 'hope'. Easily tricked by scarcity and FOMO.

Better to go in eyes wide open.

If you do hire a coach, consultant, mentor, be ok with doing the work. Commit to the process. Follow through.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Unlocking Your Teams Potential - The Roles of Confidence and Creativity to Leading a Team

image
Unlocking Your Teams Potential - The Roles of Confidence and Creativity to Leading a Team
Shane Melanson

This weekend, my daughter was in a soccer tournament, where her team was playing up an age. Now, if you have a daughter, you know that there is a big difference between an 11/12 and 13/14 year old girls. 

Our team was smaller - but they had something no other team had.  They focused on moving the ball and playing as a team vs 1 superstar trying to do it all.

John (their coach) set the focus of the team before the 1st game: if you want to go fast, go alone.  If you want to go further, go together (cliche - but true).

The girls took it to heart and ended up going all the way to the final, winning silver.

During lunch before the last game, I was sitting with John and had an opportunity to ask questions to better understand his philosophy on coaching.

The main takeaway: with your kids, you want to protect their confidence and creativity. 

I would add, they need to have fun- or they will quit. But, I suppose you could argue, increased confidence = having fun.

When I look at the Kalamoir team, I see how transferable this philosophy is. In construction & development we are problem solving every day.  

By definition - solving a problem requires new thinking -> creativity.  

To feel comfortable to solve the problem - one needs the underlying confidence to do that. 

Some adults/kids, have innate confidence and will take action without hesitation.

But the majority do not and need to have this confidence and creativity cultivated.

This is where the coach (and team) come in. How do you empower your team to tap into this creativity? 

Brooke, was new to her team.  The team had been together for 6+ years and now an outsider was asked to come in.

In the first game, she played her heart out.  The coach kept the game plan simple and they ended up winning 2-1 against a much bigger  and I would argue skilled team.

But, our girls played together and every one contributed.

At the end of the game- the players get to pick the MVP.  They picked Brooke (she got the superwoman cape).  

As they gave her the cape (and any other girl could have been chosen that game) - I thought how cool it was that the girls understood the importance of making Brooke feel part of the team.

No better way to boost someone’s confidence than to recognize them. 

They not only accepted Brooke, they trusted her and brought her into the team. And they did this in 1 day.

It has me thinking of ways to get new team members (3 starting with us shortly) how to get them feeling like they are part of the team sooner, so they can contribute and feel confident doing so.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

In the book A Man For All Markets, by Ed Thorpe he tells the story of meeting Warren Buffett in the 1960’s. 

After their meeting, Ed tells his wife, Warren will be the richest man in the US.   At the time Warren was worth about $25M or so.

Why did Ed make this statement?

Ed (a PhD in mathematics) figured that if Warren, (an extremely smart investor), would continue to compound his money at 20%/year there would be no way he could not become the wealthiest man in the US.

This is not about compounding your money (there are enough books already written on that).

Here's the important part - I think the reason Ed made this statement was because he saw that Warren had created & followed very specific principles and rules for investing. 

He was a disciplined and smart investor. (I don't think you can be successful for the long term without both traits).

The equation: compound disciplined investing principles x 30 years = exponential results.  

Compare this philosophy to how I have invested for the 15 years... where I have not followed a set of clear investing principles (until now).

I prided my self on being opportunistic. 

Chasing deals across Can and the US in any asset classes.

Value add apartments

Retail development

Small bay industrial condos

Mobile home parks

Private mortgages

townhouse infills

Never realizing on the compounding effect (knowledge x relationships) that comes from doing multiple deals in 1 asset class.

I have seen investors do extremely well in every real estate asset class.  But, those that rise to the Warren Buffett status typically stay in their swim lane and focus.

Competing against someone with 10, 20, 50 years of experience, will crush a newbie. But, if you've got 5 or 10 deals under belt - you'll be in the top 5%.

In 2022, after much reflection, I decided to go all in on the residential rental side of real estate, primarily through new construction.

I took inventory: what I know well x unmet demand x where we had a competitive advantage investing.  

Here are few ideas on how I’m planning to invest:

  1. Taking a long term perspective (10 years minimum - but I’m thinking in terms of 30 years) to allow for compounding to really kick in

  2. Focus on areas that I have a real competitive advantage in 

  3. Focus on minimizing risk throughout the project - how can we protect our downside (so as to not get taken out of the game)

  4. Find strategic and aligned partners to help us 

  5. Refine my principles - what is working (do more) and what is not (stop)

If you have principles or rules you use for decisions making (as it relates to investing) - please share below.  I’m always learning and looking for ways to improve.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

The story of Jim and Chris… and why many new real estate developers lose money

image
The story of Jim and Chris… and why many new real estate developers lose money
Shane Melanson

Names have been changed for obvious reasons.  

This post is based on recent conversations with two developers.  Jim, his first project and Chris is a seasoned developer.

The goal of this post is to highlight how Chris thinks about risk and development and why he’s been successful.  

First meetings:

Jim: I have this land at 123 Main Street, it’s 18,000 sq.ft and I’d like to build a Multifamily project on it.  I’d like to know how much you think it will cost to build (psf)? 

How long will it take. 

How much do you charge to do this?  

Reasonable questions- but out of sequence so the answers he gets will be unsatisfactory.

Compare this with my meeting Chris for the first time.


Shane, I have a lot at 500 Maple Street. We're building a 32 unit, wood frame building with 1 level of underground. Have you built this type of project before?  What trades will you be using?  What can I expect from you during preconstruction?  Who on your team will be here and do you have the capacity to handle this project?

"Based on what I told you and assuming nothing crazy subsurface, what do you expect the cost to be (psf)?"

Here’s the big difference- Chris already KNOWS the cost, he’s not asking for information just to confirm I know what I'm talking about.

Seasoned developers come to meetings knowing most of the numbers (construction isn't magic). They are meeting to evaluate the people. If I hire you - are you going to help me solve the 100 problems that will come up. 

Jim is fixated on finding the cheapest contractor, architect and consultants. Because Jim has not other context to base his decision on - just price.

Chris is looking for the best team and will negotiate price/terms after but understands he will pay for quality & certainty.

Here is one other big difference.

Jim is trying to do all his up front work for free, hoping he can get to a DP without risking money.  

I understand that, it's why I tried too when I was new. 

No one likes to spend money without certainty. But in the world of development, it is a process to eliminate risk and some projects just don't pencil out.

Chris has a proforma and budget ready with heavy contingencies for the unknowns.  Then methodically engages consultants to zero in on the risk in the project.  

Chris is not afraid to pull the pin on the deal and kill it if he finds something that is unacceptable.

Jim on the other hand, has closed on the land and so he has very few options.

There is no turning back, so he is committed to doing the project, regardless of what he finds.  In fact, he is not asking questions like ‘what could kill me in this deal’? 

He’s asking- who can tell me what I want to hear so I can get started ASAP.

Spend enough time in the development game and you’ll hear the horror stories from developers who have the battle scars…

  • a consultant didn’t calculate the amount of electricity for your building.  You have tenants, but they can’t move in because you need a new transformer, which will take 6-9 months. (Lost Revenue of $500k + poor reputation)

  • Or, you thought you had right aways to bring in sewer, water, hydro to your building - only to find out that you need to get the neighboring property to grant you a new access.  Delaying you a year and costing an extra $150k.

In development, no 2 projects are the same.

But, with experience you come to see the biggest risks (typically subsurface) and understand there are check points along the way. 

Engaging people to help you evaluate the development on day 1 (not day 186) will cost you money - but if your team is good, they should be able to save you 2x what they charge. 

Chris appreciates the foresight and views this part of the development.  We are hired to help him.

Fred, price shops and finds someone who will tell him what he wants to hear. 9 months later, I drive by his site and construction has stopped.


Why? No idea... we weren't involved.

My first real estate mentor says this about development… Shane, there are no $1,000 (or even $10k) mistakes in development.

Don’t be shortsighted.  Invest the time and money up front to truly understand your project.


User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

On the weekend my daughter Brooke had an important soccer game.  

A little background - she plays/practices 6 days a week and loves it.  To help her, I bought an online course from a high level European soccer player.  

My thinking- you practice a lot but there are still some areas I think you could improve.  I played soccer when I was young, but wanted to get some help from someone who was playing a high level, which is why I sprung for the $497 course.  

The first 2 hours of the training was all about the importance of practicing.  To the point both my girls were bored and I was thinking I'd made a mistake. They just wanted to start on the drills.

Because I couldn’t skip ahead, I ended up watching the first videos until they could get to the 'good stuff’. 

Finally, on Sun about 90 minutes before her game, she was able to watch the first training video, a 6 minute foot work drill.

She did the drills slow and then faster, each time through.  

She didn’t have a ball, it was just coordination and agility.  

In 25 mins, I could see an improvement and said she was going to have an amazing game today.

I show up to her game right on time to see her score her 1st goal (in the first minute).  Then a few minutes later, her 2nd.  I’m thinking she might get her first hat trick - which she did before half time and then scored a fourth in the 2nd half.

Yes, I’m bragging about my daughter… but here is what I realized after the game.

I told Brooke, this 1 game could be a real turning point for you.

She has the confidence that she can do it (if you can score 4 in one game- you can do it again).

She proved to herself what she is capable of.  And, by reinforcing the idea that a bit of extra practice helped her… think of what your capable of?

This may all sound obvious.  

For me it is not.  

Growing up my coaches were old school hard asses. It was not about encouragement - they focused on mistakes and how to correct what we did wrong.  

That worked for me (but not all kids respond to that). And I mistakenly took these same ideas and philosophies into coaching my daughter and then into business.

I’m starting to realize that if you reinforce the behavior you want (vs criticize the behavior you don’t want) - it can be a powerful way to change outcomes.  

When the drive is internal and, I feel it will last longer vs constant need to motivate.  

Over the last 2 days, Brooke has been practicing on her own for hours.  Doing the drills, showing her sister, juggling the ball. 

Is this because I’m asking her to? 

No. 

Because she is proud of her accomplishments on Sunday and she is leveraging off that experience to keep going.  

At least this is my theory.  

I’m still new to this line of thinking, so if you have read any books on this or suggest any videos, please share below.  

I’m on the hunt for insights into how I can change my ways to help my girls.  Then, to see if this applies in the real world at a construction/development company. 

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Capital Raising 101: What Not to Do (a lesson from Steve Jobs)

image
Capital Raising 101: What Not to Do (a lesson from Steve Jobs)
Shane Melanson

This weekend I was reading “Working with Steve Jobs” written by Ken Kocienda.  The biggest lesson I took away from the book was how clearly Steve Jobs thinking was.  

He was able to put himself in the shoes of his customer to understand how they would feel the first time picking up an iPhone, iPad or buying music on iTunes.

How does this relate to capital raising?

Every week I’m sent investment opportunities from real estate investors looking to raise capital.  

In most cases, the pitch decks are:

  • Confusing and hard to understand

  • Complex and too long - I don’t have an hour to figure out the deal

  • Scattered (they jump all over the place)

The first deal I raised money for (in a GP/LP) was 2008.  It was a $2M capital raise, and it took me over a month, 8 hours a day to draft the first investor deck.

My mentor, Andy- would go over the memo in great detail.  It was 5 pages, 8.5 x 11.

It might take 2 hours to go through and at the end, the memo had more red ink on it than my text.  

I’d rewrite it, and we'd go through the exercise again.  Red Ink, change this.  

What does this mean? 

Then why don’t you say that? 

I don’t understand all these calculations - simplify it.

What is this picture supposed to be telling me? Why are we using it?

Andy would take an incredible amount of time to go through the deck.  Reading it as if it was the first time he’d seen the deal.  Putting himself in the shoes of an investor - who would be seeing it for the first time. 

And this is the biggest mistake I see capital raisers making… assuming an investor has the same background and context on your deal as you.

They don’t.

HNW investors are busy.

They are being sent deals every week to look at.  They are busy so you need to have an investor deck that is concise and to the point.  

As capital raisers, we are too close to our deals.  

I can tell by looking at 2 pages if a capital raiser knows what they are doing.  Based on the image and headline of the cover page and their executive summary- I should know what this deal is about. 

I used to think - the more details I put into a deck the better.  That it would impress investors.

Now, I understand, that you only have a few minutes of attention (max) when dealing with HNW investors.

They don’t have time to connect the dots.  If its confusing - they will assume you don’t really understand the business.

(This is also where they will start asking you a bunch of questions on your #’ers and assumptions- which generally leads you off course).

Over the years and having had several mentors (including Oren Klaff) - I now organize an investor presentation using this general framework:

Cover page

Disclaimers

Table of Contents

1 Page Executive Summary (I can look at this 1 page and know the entire deal)

Big Idea (under 250 words)

Macro Location

Property

Business Plan

Financials & Returns (simplified)

Timelines/Milestones

Deal Structure

Team

Sometimes it changes a bit - but that can be done in about 12 pages (often, I have less text/page so it could be 20 pages).

The first draft might be 40 pages.  It takes time to cut out anything that is not essential.  

I will show my girls (11 and 9) - here is what I’m doing.  Does this make sense?  Tell me what you think I'm doing?

Dad, it looks like you’re building 63 townhouses in Chestermere and you are going to rent them out.  And you need $3M. 

Good, I’m on the right track.  

There is an art and science to raising money.  I’m still learning and investing in my education to get better.  

Finding your own Steve Jobs or Andy to look over your presentation to help you get crystal clear can be difference between raising the money or not.  

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

What’s your angle?

image
What’s your angle?
Shane Melanson

Shane, why are you posting on LinkedIn & Twitter? 

A question a guy asked me this week during an interesting conversation that started from a post on LinkedIn.

Ok, there are a few reasons I started writing again. If you went back to my Facebook page circa 2017/18, you’d see some of my first articles shared.

Here is why I do this:

First - I want track and share my business lessons for me and maybe one day my kids.  Taking the time to write them out helps me clarify the lesson (so I don't make the same mistakes) and continually grow.

In the process of documenting these lessons, I suspect they will likely help others too.   

Next - Investing in real estate is about relationships and connections. 

When I had more time, I would spend be on the phone or having coffees to stay on the radar of brokers, sellers, developers and industry pros.

As I got busier with our construction company and developments- I had less time to network.

My podcast, The Investing Advantage is one way that I’m able to stay connected.  But, I figured writing on LinkedIn would add extra times to be in front of people.

The Results:

Each post only gets a handful of comments/likes per post.

But, I’m not really optimizing for that. 

It only takes 1 person to call me with a townhouse or Multifamily site in Calgary for it to actually pay off.  When more people know who I am, what I’m looking for - the more likely I see the right opportunities.

Several of our team at Kalamoir read my posts and is just another way to stay connected.  

And I have heard from 10 or so people this week that they appreciate my posts - which is a good feeling. It has led to a few really interesting conversations. 

Sometimes conversations lead to lifelong friends. 

A post -> DM -> email-> call -> meeting ->friendship  

One last thought on writing and publishing.  

For the longest time I was too fearful of the opinions of 1 or 2 key people in my life.  Thinking they would judge and criticize me for writing.

Before I would publish - I’d ask myself: what will John, Or Frank think of this?  Maybe I should water it down or not say something.  

I was censoring my ideas and thoughts to the point that I had nothing interesting to say.  

If you have something to share and it could help someone else, I feel it’s a worth the uncomfortable reality that some people will judge you.  

I’m not sure the fear ever goes away 100% - but, I’ve learned to get past it.  Because the feedback from those who do read is overwhelmingly positive.  

So, if you’re on the fence of whether you should share an idea or thought… if you think it could help someone, I’d say go for it:  Benefits > Risk

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Why Blaming Others Actually Feels Worse than Taking 100% Responsibly.

image
Why Blaming Others Actually Feels Worse than Taking 100% Responsibly.
Shane Melanson

Recently I had to deal with a very difficult business challenge. 

My first reaction was to look around and find all the people that had screwed up.  I had a big list.  

  • banker

  • planners

  • architect and consultants

  • the market

  • tenants

  • suppliers

What was interesting, was that after I'd made my list, it didn’t make me feel better.  It actually made me feel worse.   The list highlighted all the things that were outside of my control and I felt helpless.

When I get into these negative modes, I typically go for runs or get outside. On my run, I like to listen to podcasts or audio books. On this run, I put on a Jim Rohn book with the topic of having a personal philosophy of taking 100% responsibility for your life.  

I'd heard this concept before, but today is hit home.

To blame others was to give control to others.  

Because I value control, blaming meant someone else could dictate my outcome.  I didn’t like that thought. 

Regardless of whether I ‘should’ take full responsibility - I realized by taking ownership of everything, I felt better. 

Blaming (even when it's justified) - was not helpful. 

This is what was bothering me so much.  My blaming made me feel worse - because it highlighted I was not in control.  I was at the effect of everyone else.

On the run, I started to ask - what if everything was really my responsibility.  Everything.

  • The mistakes

  • The fact that I didn’t know something

  • That fact that someone else was hired to do a job and screwed it up

  • The fact that someone said they were going to do it - and then they didn’t or they did a bad job.

All of this, I could take ownership on. (Side note - Navy Seal, Joko Willink book, Extreme Ownership talks about this in detail too).  

Taking ownership gave me confidence that I could solve the problem.

My mind was focused on asking the right questions. How was I going to solve the problem.  I could impact the outcome based on MY Actions.  Not waiting or hoping that it would get better.

I sat down for an hour and did a deep dive on what led to the situation (facts, no pointing fingers).  So I could clearly understand and then diagnose  the problem.

Once the problem was clear (the problem was NOT someone else) - I came up with a plan to solve it.  And contingencies if that plan didn’t work.

The other realization was that I needed help from others.

But, when I was pointing the finger at everyone else - no quality people wanted to help me.  Who wants to help someone who is negative or blaming others (other negative people). 

Winners want to be around winners. And winners take ownership.  

When I shifted my mindset, I could focus on the outcome and direct my energy to solving the problem.  When I was blaming, my energy was draining me (and others). 

Leaders do take the initiative because they are accountable for the outcome.  They are self reliant.  They don’t look around waiting for someone else to act.

The best part… it’s a choice.  

I had the choice to blame  - and the choice to take ownership.

Our personal philosophy, how we interpret things, is up to us.  Are you a default blamer (out of control) or default ownership (it’s up to me). 

I still catch myself blaming.  It’s a bad habit that I need to be reminded of.  This post is a reminder: what choice am I making today?

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

When should you cross the bridge from raising money for a single deal to a fund?

Last week a friend asked me to help his buddy who wanted to raise money for his new venture.  

I don’t really consult on this type of work anymore, but said I’d jump on a quick call to see if I could help. 

I’ll cut straight to the point- the guy (let’s call him John) wanted to start a fund raising 10M for a new concept. I asked a few questions and could tell quickly that this plan was not fully baked. 

The team had no track record for what they were doing and in 10 minutes had poked several big holes in their plan.  

I told John, maybe you could start a fund and it would work - but if it was me- here’s how I’d get started:

  1. Proof of concept. A fund is selling an idea. Without a track record why would I invest?  Too high risk. Instead- find a property/biz you plan to turn around and execute. Refine your process on 1 and deliver a result 

  2. Start small- and have meaningful skin in the game. 

  3. Record everything and share the wins and losses. People want to know you’ve learned some lessons and smart investors know it’s never a straight line to success

  4. Find another project and execute. 

  5. Take a 10-15 year perspective and look at a fund once you have a well defined strategy and track record. Now you can point to exactly the type of properties/ biz you invest in and why. Your team is solid. 

Fund sounds sexy.  Everyone wants to raise money, because they have a great idea.

And in your money raising journey you’ll meet service providers all too eager to take your money saying they can help you. Great idea! Love it!. We can help you with that! … to get started, here's my retainer... this will be fun!

Investors will take your meetings and say they'll get back to you.

But nothing counts until someone writes you a check (or wires you money). At the point when someone is going to send you $100k, $500k or $1M, that is when people start asking the tough questions.  A

I figure - why not ask Jon the tough questions now, so he's not caught off guard or delusional on what is expected.

Am I jaded -> Yes. 

I spent more than a year trying to raise a $75M fund.  Meeting with Private Equity, Hedge Funds, Family Offices… and even with a track record, strong team, we failed (I wasn't prepared to raise money on the terms we were given).  

Many false starts with people who say they are in- only to change the terms or their mind last minute. 

I’d rather arm John with proper expectations today so he can prepare appropriately.

A few shifts in mindset: taking a longer term approach to building his business and how to raise capital:

  • Build your track record.  

  • Raise your first $1M.  

  • Work out the kinks in your plan.  

  • Figure out what type of investors you want in your projects.  Hint - all investors (money) are not equal.  

Starting out - you’ll take anyone’s money.  But, do a couple of deals and you’ll quickly appreciate there are some great investors and others you wish you'd never let in.

Only experience can teach you this. 

But, my hope was that our conversation or this post saves even 1 person from investing a year (and possibly tens of thousands) going down the wrong path

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

What Chess Taught Me About Investing

image
What Chess Taught Me About Investing
Shane Melanson

On my morning run I was listening to Tim Ferris interview Josh Watkin - world champion in chess as they discussed how to become world class in any pursuit.

I thought about investing and those who were world class.  A few come to mind - Warren Buffett, Ray Dalio, Howard Marks and Sam Zell.  If you study them - you'll see they use principles to help make decisions and evaluate Risk. 

I thought of my investing track record.  

Before I had clear investing principles-I invested mainly on emotion (Greed, FOMO).  In 2 situations, I lost all my money (age 18 and 28).

I didn’t ask the right questions. 

I was focused on the upside. 

I assumed the deal would work out and starting counting my money too early.

(Side note- both people I trusted to invest with were salesman, not operators. They had virtually no expertise.  Back then, I didn’t know what I didn’t know.) 

Losing money is painful and caused me to take inventory.  

Why did I lose my money?

How do I prevent this from happening again?

What could I do differently next time?

I started talking to people who were successful.  As an commercial lender, I was lucky to be around wealthy investors.  I asked questions constantly -trying to get an understanding of how they viewed the world.

It took years, but I eventually created my own rules or non-negotiables for investing.  (I’m not suggesting these are unique to me or that you adopt them).  

Here are a few that I have found to be the most helpful:

  1. invest in what I understand.

  2. Invest where I have a competitive advantage (generally an informational advantage)

  3. Invest in what I can control/influence the outcome

  4. Invest for cash flow (not appreciation or speculation)

  5. Invest in things I believe my kids will benefit from in 20 years.  

I’m not suggesting these rules are universal.  They work for me, based on what I want and what I don’t want.

Having a simple set of rules/principles to come back to - make it easier to decide what to invest in. 

Who to invest with.  Where you put your money.

Like chess, when someone makes a move- you likely have a counter move. You learn this, either through trial and error or by watching others.

Either way, you take what works and create principles. Will the principles protect you 100% of the time?


No. But they should prevent 90% or more of the most common and avoidable errors.

The last thing I would say about investing - is I’m highly skeptical of people who put unnecessary pressure on me to make a decision fast. 

As my father-in-law says- if you need a fast answer, it’s NO.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Most decisions we make are 2 way doors.

image
Most decisions we make are 2 way doors.
Shane Melanson

If we make a mistake we can still go back. Only a few are 1 way doors - irreversible. -paraphrasing Jeff Bezos

I thought this was an important framework for making decisions.

When you study Amazon/Bezos, it’s evident they are testing new ideas often.  They want to know will this work?

Only 1 way to find out- test it...  Run an experiment.

In the past, I’ve been the guy who asks lots of questions.  Could this work?  What happens if this happens.

Taking too long to take action on something that could be corrected or wouldn’t have any long term impacts.  

As I started to surround myself with more successful people - I noticed they make decisions much quicker.  They are not interested in theories.  They say - go test it and lets see what happens.  

There is a bias for fast action.

Now this is where the wisdom of Jeff’s quote comes in- 2 way doors vs 1 way doors.

Betting the farm on a 1 way door is not what I’m talking about.

My Examples of 1 way doors (irreversible or would take a long time to unwind):

Who you marry

Having kids or not

The city you live in

Buying/Investing in certain real estate

Business Partnerships

Starting a business (a business with employees) 

These decisions require far more consideration - because the consequences of a wrong decisions are not so easy (or impossible) to unwind.  

2 Way Doors

What books or podcasts you read

Job you take 

Investing in Stock Market

Sports you play

One more point- a 2 way door for me - might be a 1 way for you.  The point is to know the difference for you when you’re making a decision.

Taking a real estate investment as example - it’s easy to get into a deal (2 way door - you can look at lots of properties, tour them) - but it can be hard to get out (you need a buyer).

Buyers have choices.

When you’re the seller - you are a taker.

From 2011 - 2022, with Demand > Supply in most markets, it was good to be an owner and seller.  You had an abundance of options, and gave the illusion of investing in real estate as a 2 way door.  

You could unload it fast and likely for a profit. 

Today, the pendulum has swung the other way.  Fewer buyers and harder to secure debt.  

Those who own inferior real estate or overpaid (FOMO) - will be stuck managing for a while.  

If you own great assets, you won’t mind holding them, until the market turns back for you.  You have options.

As I write this, it seems 2 way doors mean more options.  1 way doors are binary.  

It’s the first I’ve written about this concept and if you have a different perspective, I’d like to hear about it.  

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Why am I including a picture of my daughter Blake - when I'm talking about debt? This was a daddy-daughter date in Kelowna. 5 Years earlier, I had to leave our Kelowna family trip to tend to a struggling development.

I have a few philosophies on leverage - for cash flowing commercial real estate.

There is the temptation to push the debt limits to boost returns.  

  • The beliefs rents will rise.  

  • That Interest rates will stay flat or fall.  

  • A growing market, will keep the demand high for our asset.

In my experience, flying too close to the sun, running low DCR’s - is dangerous.   The world is unpredictable.  Things happen (outside of our control) and we (investors) are forced to deal with them.

If your debt load is too high (meaning you need to inject capital to solve the problem) - you’re adding stress to your life.

I’ve lived this and it’s never pleasant to have to inject more money into a deal.  Even if your business model calls for it on day 1 - in my experience, people underestimate the event of the cash call. 

They say yes today - believing it’s black swan even, unlikely to happen.

With several battle scars over the years - today, I'm a conservative investor.  When you’re young, taking on more risk make sense.

If you make a mistake - you have the energy and time to make up for it.  As you get older, you have less time (patience) and the energy you have is  better invested with family, health etc.

*One of my philosophies on investing - is to give you more choices on what you can do.  If you hamstring yourself with high levels of debt where you’re looking over your shoulder - you’re limiting your choices.  

I doubt there is a singular answer to this question.  

Beliefs shaped from experiences.  

When I was new to commercial real estate and saw how far I could lever up a property- I was full tilt.  Let’s buy as much as we could.

It took my mentors and investors to reel me back in. 

Shane - what happens if I rates go up?  What happens if you don’t hit your projected rents?  What happens if your business plan takes longer?  What happens if the government… 

16 years of investing and projects not going as per script...

  • Covid. 

  • I rates doubling in less than a year. 

  • Oil dropping from 110/bbl to $30/bbl. 

There are too many pot holes in the world of investing.   I like to take vacations with my family and remain present. I don't like waking up 3x night, wondering how I'm going to make the payment to my bank (let alone tell investors we are not making distributions).

As Buffett says - even a big number * 0 = 0.  

If you have thoughts on this topic (for or against mine) - please let me know. 

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

A. Your customer.

Obsesses over your customer.  Look for ways to cut unnecessary costs and shorten the time it takes to deliver.  

Both Bezos and Buffett emphasis the importance of focusing their energy on the customer to building a sustainable business.  This is what widens the moat around your business.

What can you do to focus on the customer?  

  • Be the low cost provider (Amazon)

  • Delivering with consistency and predictability (Disney) 

  • Innovating and creating products customers want (Apple)

As a developer I wanted predictability and certainty of outcome.  Here's my budget and timeline - can you hit it?  Low cost is important - but, not at the expense of quality, safety or time.

One of my first developments, in 2011 - the plan was to service 55 lots in Phase 1.  There was a misunderstanding and the civil contractor serviced 110 lots. 

Problem - we had money for 55.  

Now, their screw up was my problem to fix.  A cash call before Christmas drives home the pain of this error. 

I took for granted our trades and consultants understood our plans and what we needed. 

Besides the obvious, I wanted to understand how to avoid it from happening again.  

I was a new developer & trusting.  I had not inspected their work, or taken the time question everything.  (Looking back, I believe it was a of lack of skills, laziness & trying to be liked).

12 years and multiple developments projects, I was interviewing a new GC to help with a townhouse project. It was the first time meeting Mark (now we partners).

He took the opposite approach to construction.  

Mark: I assume it’s all screwed up until they (consultants/trades) can prove otherwise.

In practice this means asking more questions.  It means taking weeks to go through everything in detail.  It means putting people on notice they are wrong and to fix it.

It’s not personal.  

The Goal is simple: happy customers.

To have a happy customer, they need to be successful.  No one wins when a project goes off track.

Taking the extra time upfront to do the hard work, the uncomfortable conversations is what makes the difference.

Could other companies do this?

Yes.

Do other companies do this?

In my experience it takes a unique individual with the persistence, broad knowledge of construction and tact to get this done efficiently. The entire team needs to be on the same page.

Like a coach getting everyone to work together to succeed. It does no good to have your wide receiver with 180 yards just to lose the game.

In the construction companies I've met in my time, there are may be 1 or 2 people with these skills. 

Keeping your customer in mind  - focusing relentlessly on what they want -> means avoiding mistakes before they happen.

It will never be perfect, but that doesn’t mean you don’t push for excellence. But the companies who can do this - will widen the moat.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Real Estate Development Mistakes Learned over the past 12 years

image
Real Estate Development Mistakes Learned over the past 12 years
Shane Melanson

A few days ago, I was contacted by a real estate investor to help him get into commercial real estate development. I'm in the process of drafting a blog post to answer that - but today I want to focus on the this question:

“What early development mistakes will you never make again?”

As someone who takes notes & tracks my journey to investing, I'll share a handful of mistakes I have made or seen others make.

Let’s jump in:

Mistake #1: Overly Optimistic

Too often, investors are what I call Bluesky thinkers.

We focus on all the good things that can happen - instead of taking a step back and assessing what are all the things that could go wrong.

In early 2022, we could see inflation was an issue and I rates were going to go up. We stress tested our models. But, I feel we stress tested to the point that the model would no longer work - vs. asking, what if I rates go to 10%?

Something that would have seemed crazy in Jan 2022 - but in Jan 2023, with Prime at 6.45% + 1.5- 2% spreads on construction loans, not so crazy.

This is best done through Accurate Thinking and having an outside perspective.

Someone with no horse in the race who can be a sounding board. Very view people have this ability to be accurate thinkers (I'm fortunate to have some great partners and people I can call on for this).

In many cases - the deal is just a bad deal.

Walking away (even if you have 100k in Due Diligence) is the right decision.

Mistake #2: Going into a Deal with too little margin of safety.

My brother-in-law Graeme, gave me advice on developments: Double your time and the costs (on civil) and if it's still a good deal, keep going.

I have not always followed this advice, but in time have come to see it's wisdom. One delay by a utility provider, or DP or BP can easily double your timelines.

We stress tested Interest Rates, Rental Rates - but rarely do we stress test delivery times. The time to get to market can have huge impacts on cash flow - to the point, you can run out of money on your interest reserve.

It doesn't take much to delay your project 6-12 months.

Mistake #3: The Wrong Team

Until you’ve done a few developments, it's hard to know what to look for in contractors, architects, consultants, trades etc.

"Penny wise - pound foolish".

Good example - going with the 'low' quote to pick your consultant. Only to find out they are hard to work with. They get mired in the small things and ignore the big picture.

End result- they create delays and unnecessary delays driving costs up.

Fights with the planners, and contractors.

One horrible consultants can ruin your project. Take extra time in building your team. Where everyone is on the same page and there to support you.

Do they understand who is writing their checks - and are they helpful or does their ego get in the way of executing?

Mistake #4: Under Estimating Contingences

Traditional wisdom says carry a 5- 10% contingency.

But that’s only true if you have a project big enough and far along enough in the bid process.

  • A 10% contingency on 10M = $1M (probably good).

  • 10% on a 2M project = $200k (that can go over budget fast with a few things missed)

The size of your actual contingency is key.

If it's a new project, new area, new team - the variables and opportunities for mistakes increase. I'd rather look at whole dollar amounts on contingencies for a gut check.

How many mistakes will this absorb? Ask your GC, what level of budget are they giving you? Often times it's a Class D budget (within 20%) - yet most developers don't hear this. And they plug in this # hoping it will be within 5% - not accounting for any Geotech/civil issues.

Mistake #5: Not Constantly Revising Your Financial Model

We think that a model that took 2 days to put together is going to be good for all projects.

We feel that we've underwritten these projects 100x - we're good to change the name on a proforma, update the # of units or sq.ft and save time.

Yet, we don't go through to see if every cell and calculation is pulling the right info. Maybe someone hard coded a cell. Maybe someone accidently missed a cost or overstated income.

One mistakes amplifies in a profoma that can be the difference between a good deal or one you should pass on.

Just because you underwrote the deal in detail once - doesn't mean you can just update a few numbers and it will be good to go.

It's slopy and lazy.

Much better to operate from first principles, and start from scratch when starting a new development proforma.

Those are a few of the issues I have tracked on my Notes tab on my iphone. The actual list is much longer, but these should help.

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Yesterday I got a text from a friend who owns a commercial property with a tenant coming up for renewal.

Q. how much should I be paying the property manager or leasing agent for a renewal?

A. there is no typical fee.  Every market is different.  Here is how I answered it.  

My friend (landlord) also wanted to know, should he deal direct with tenant?  Use his property manager or the original leasing agent?

Lots to consider. 

Here are the 4 Strategies for dealing with commercial tenant renewals:

Step 1.  Is it a Tenant or Landlord Market?

I want to know who has the power in the deal.  If you’re in a landlord market (low vacancy) and you have 5M sq.ft of space, you have leverage. 1 tenant vacancy isn't going to hurt you.

On the flip side, if you’re a smaller investor, and the tenant represents 40% of your NOI, in a market with 18% vacant- I'd suggest the tenant has leverage on you. They have options. And, best to use a pro for help.

Step 2.  What is your plan for the building?

If you’re looking to sell soon - it might makes sense to ‘buy up the face rate’ of the lease.  

Offer more in Tenant improvements, free rent, or other inducements to push the rental rate.

If you’re planning to hold for 10-20 years, I'd look to secure the tenant for a longer lease. 

Maybe you need to give something to get them to stay longer.

Parking.  Paint. Carpet.  Add a new amenity in the building.

Step 3.  Who to use in the negotiation?

This one is dicey.  I tend to lean to using the professionals (leasing agents/property managers).

I think long term. 

If you cut the broker out on the renewal, guess what -> he may call the tenant direct and tell them he found them a better building at lower rates just down the street. CRE leasing can be cut throat.

I want to the deck in my favor and that often means keep leasing agents paid.   

Step 4. How much do you Pay?

Find out what the going rate is for new leases - then cut it in half (that’s typical in my market).  

Ex. Retail leasing might be 5% for years 1-5 and 2.5% for years 6-10. Office might be $2 per foot.

Take the rate and offer 1/2 a fee.

Much easier (as a landlord and leasing agent) to do a renewal than a new lease. 1/2 a fee is reasonable. 

If tenant leaves & you need to backfill, downtime, commissions, fixturing, free rent etc - 1/2 a fee is going to give you a higher NER (net effective rent) than a new lease.

TL;DR

  1. Tenant or Landlord Market?

  2. Long Term Plan for building?

  3. Using a Broker or Negotiate yourself?

  4. How much to pay?

For more ideas and stories on investing in commercial real estate check out my podcast - The Investing Advantage here:

User Avatar

Shane Melanson

3y ago

Wisdom Is Prevention...

image
Wisdom Is Prevention...
Shane Melanson

I think Buffett said this - meaning it's better to avoid a mistake before it happens.

Sounds easy enough... just avoid making stupid mistakes. But, no one goes into a deal thinking it will be a bad one. We focus on the upside. Bluesky optimism that I rates will be low again, the rents will be higher.

And, then a black swan event (or so we think) occurs and we take a loss.

There are different types of investors.

The Arm Chair Quarterback... 

Investors who never take the shot - so they never miss.  On the sidelines and criticizing and talking about all the reasons one will fail. It doesn't take a genius to come up with reasons something won't work. You can always talk yourself out of a deal.

The Speculator...

The person who is in the game and is taking wild shots. Throwing hail mary's on every play. If 1 sticks, it will make up for the losses. In real estate, that rarely happens. Because a loss is generally amplified with leverage. So, real estate investors can't afford many air balls.

The Committed...

The investor who takes the long term approach. Taking calculated shots. Some miss the mark, but not by much. They may lose a bit or breakeven, but they live to see another day.

They take these lessons and apply them to the next round. Honing their skills at every opportunity so that they don’t make the same mistake again. 

This is where wisdom compounds with time.

The goal is to become a professional. To have a high level of confidence that before you take the shot - knowing it will score? Maybe not 100% accuracy, but pretty damn close.

Why am I sharing this?

I’ve been investing in real estate since 2003/04. 

I have invested in many different asset classes (industrial, multifamily, retail, mortgages, land, land lease, ground up development). Which has given me perspective on the industry but, not the wisdom of someone who has committed to mastering 1 asset class.

This year I've come to see the importance on mastering an asset class and going all in (more on that later).

The wisdom that only comes when you have done 5, or 10 or 20 of a similar type of project. Where you can stack the lessons from previous projects and apply them to the next one.

Here's the truth - It’s easy to get into a deal. It's much harder to get out.

  1. Commit to mastering 1 asset class.

  2. Take extra time upfront to avoid the mistakes. 

  3. If you're new, find someone with wisdom (and unbiased) to guide you. Pay for their wisdom if that's what it takes.

A reminder for me when I get off track and chase the next great 'opportunity'.