User Avatar

Sharing thoughts on real estate investing, construction, development and raising money

Real Estate Development Mistakes Learned over the past 12 years

image
Real Estate Development Mistakes Learned over the past 12 years
Shane Melanson

A few days ago, I was contacted by a real estate investor to help him get into commercial real estate development. I'm in the process of drafting a blog post to answer that - but today I want to focus on the this question:

“What early development mistakes will you never make again?”

As someone who takes notes & tracks my journey to investing, I'll share a handful of mistakes I have made or seen others make.

Let’s jump in:

Mistake #1: Overly Optimistic

Too often, investors are what I call Bluesky thinkers.

We focus on all the good things that can happen - instead of taking a step back and assessing what are all the things that could go wrong.

In early 2022, we could see inflation was an issue and I rates were going to go up. We stress tested our models. But, I feel we stress tested to the point that the model would no longer work - vs. asking, what if I rates go to 10%?

Something that would have seemed crazy in Jan 2022 - but in Jan 2023, with Prime at 6.45% + 1.5- 2% spreads on construction loans, not so crazy.

This is best done through Accurate Thinking and having an outside perspective.

Someone with no horse in the race who can be a sounding board. Very view people have this ability to be accurate thinkers (I'm fortunate to have some great partners and people I can call on for this).

In many cases - the deal is just a bad deal.

Walking away (even if you have 100k in Due Diligence) is the right decision.

Mistake #2: Going into a Deal with too little margin of safety.

My brother-in-law Graeme, gave me advice on developments: Double your time and the costs (on civil) and if it's still a good deal, keep going.

I have not always followed this advice, but in time have come to see it's wisdom. One delay by a utility provider, or DP or BP can easily double your timelines.

We stress tested Interest Rates, Rental Rates - but rarely do we stress test delivery times. The time to get to market can have huge impacts on cash flow - to the point, you can run out of money on your interest reserve.

It doesn't take much to delay your project 6-12 months.

Mistake #3: The Wrong Team

Until you’ve done a few developments, it's hard to know what to look for in contractors, architects, consultants, trades etc.

"Penny wise - pound foolish".

Good example - going with the 'low' quote to pick your consultant. Only to find out they are hard to work with. They get mired in the small things and ignore the big picture.

End result- they create delays and unnecessary delays driving costs up.

Fights with the planners, and contractors.

One horrible consultants can ruin your project. Take extra time in building your team. Where everyone is on the same page and there to support you.

Do they understand who is writing their checks - and are they helpful or does their ego get in the way of executing?

Mistake #4: Under Estimating Contingences

Traditional wisdom says carry a 5- 10% contingency.

But that’s only true if you have a project big enough and far along enough in the bid process.

  • A 10% contingency on 10M = $1M (probably good).

  • 10% on a 2M project = $200k (that can go over budget fast with a few things missed)

The size of your actual contingency is key.

If it's a new project, new area, new team - the variables and opportunities for mistakes increase. I'd rather look at whole dollar amounts on contingencies for a gut check.

How many mistakes will this absorb? Ask your GC, what level of budget are they giving you? Often times it's a Class D budget (within 20%) - yet most developers don't hear this. And they plug in this # hoping it will be within 5% - not accounting for any Geotech/civil issues.

Mistake #5: Not Constantly Revising Your Financial Model

We think that a model that took 2 days to put together is going to be good for all projects.

We feel that we've underwritten these projects 100x - we're good to change the name on a proforma, update the # of units or sq.ft and save time.

Yet, we don't go through to see if every cell and calculation is pulling the right info. Maybe someone hard coded a cell. Maybe someone accidently missed a cost or overstated income.

One mistakes amplifies in a profoma that can be the difference between a good deal or one you should pass on.

Just because you underwrote the deal in detail once - doesn't mean you can just update a few numbers and it will be good to go.

It's slopy and lazy.

Much better to operate from first principles, and start from scratch when starting a new development proforma.

Those are a few of the issues I have tracked on my Notes tab on my iphone. The actual list is much longer, but these should help.