Shane Melanson
3y ago
Sharing thoughts on real estate investing, construction, development and raising money
Yesterday I got a text from a friend who owns a commercial property with a tenant coming up for renewal.
Q. how much should I be paying the property manager or leasing agent for a renewal?
A. there is no typical fee. Every market is different. Here is how I answered it.
My friend (landlord) also wanted to know, should he deal direct with tenant? Use his property manager or the original leasing agent?
Lots to consider.
Here are the 4 Strategies for dealing with commercial tenant renewals:
Step 1. Is it a Tenant or Landlord Market?
I want to know who has the power in the deal. If you’re in a landlord market (low vacancy) and you have 5M sq.ft of space, you have leverage. 1 tenant vacancy isn't going to hurt you.
On the flip side, if you’re a smaller investor, and the tenant represents 40% of your NOI, in a market with 18% vacant- I'd suggest the tenant has leverage on you. They have options. And, best to use a pro for help.
Step 2. What is your plan for the building?
If you’re looking to sell soon - it might makes sense to ‘buy up the face rate’ of the lease.
Offer more in Tenant improvements, free rent, or other inducements to push the rental rate.
If you’re planning to hold for 10-20 years, I'd look to secure the tenant for a longer lease.
Maybe you need to give something to get them to stay longer.
Parking. Paint. Carpet. Add a new amenity in the building.
Step 3. Who to use in the negotiation?
This one is dicey. I tend to lean to using the professionals (leasing agents/property managers).
I think long term.
If you cut the broker out on the renewal, guess what -> he may call the tenant direct and tell them he found them a better building at lower rates just down the street. CRE leasing can be cut throat.
I want to the deck in my favor and that often means keep leasing agents paid.
Step 4. How much do you Pay?
Find out what the going rate is for new leases - then cut it in half (that’s typical in my market).
Ex. Retail leasing might be 5% for years 1-5 and 2.5% for years 6-10. Office might be $2 per foot.
Take the rate and offer 1/2 a fee.
Much easier (as a landlord and leasing agent) to do a renewal than a new lease. 1/2 a fee is reasonable.
If tenant leaves & you need to backfill, downtime, commissions, fixturing, free rent etc - 1/2 a fee is going to give you a higher NER (net effective rent) than a new lease.
TL;DR
Tenant or Landlord Market?
Long Term Plan for building?
Using a Broker or Negotiate yourself?
How much to pay?
For more ideas and stories on investing in commercial real estate check out my podcast - The Investing Advantage here: